Reid A J, Biringer A, Carroll J D, Midmer D, Wilson L M, Chalmers B, Stewart D E
Department of Family and Community Medicine, University of Toronto, Ont.
CMAJ. 1998 Sep 22;159(6):677-84.
The assessment of the psychosocial health of pregnant women and their families, although recommended, is not carried out by most practitioners. One reason is the lack of a practical and evidence-based tool. In response, a multidisciplinary group created the Antenatal Psychosocial Health Assessment (ALPHA) form. This article describes the development of this tool and experience with it in an initial field trial.
A systematic literature review revealed 15 antenatal psychosocial risk factors associated with poor postpartum family outcomes of woman abuse, child abuse, postpartum depression, marital/couple dysfunction and increased physical illness. The ALPHA form, incorporating these risk factors, was developed and refined through several focus groups. It was then used by 5 obstetricians, 10 family physicians, 7 midwives and 4 antenatal clinic nurses in various urban, rural and culturally diverse locations across Ontario. After 3 months, these health care providers met in focus groups to discuss their experiences. A sample of pregnant women assessed using the ALPHA form were interviewed about their experience as well. Results were analysed according to qualitative methods.
The final version of the ALPHA form grouped the 15 risk factors into 4 categories--family factors, maternal factors, substance abuse and family violence--with suggested questions for each area of enquiry. The health care providers uniformly reported that the form helped them to uncover new and often surprising information, even when the women were well known to them. Incorporating the form into practice was usually accomplished after a period of familiarization. Most of the providers said the form was useful and would continue to use it if it became part of standard care. The pregnant women in the sample said they valued the enquiry and felt comfortable with the process, unless there were large cultural barriers.
The ALPHA form appears to be an important tool in assessing psychosocial health in pregnancy and to be readily integrated into practice. More study is required to quantify the number of risks identified and resources used, to determine the form's reliability and validity and, ultimately, to assess the effect of its use on postpartum outcomes.
尽管建议对孕妇及其家庭的心理社会健康进行评估,但大多数从业者并未开展此项工作。原因之一是缺乏实用且基于证据的工具。作为回应,一个多学科小组创建了产前心理社会健康评估(ALPHA)表。本文描述了该工具的开发过程及其在初步现场试验中的应用经验。
系统的文献综述揭示了15个与产后家庭不良结局相关的产前心理社会风险因素,包括妇女虐待、儿童虐待、产后抑郁、婚姻/夫妻功能障碍以及身体疾病增加。纳入这些风险因素的ALPHA表通过多个焦点小组进行了开发和完善。然后,安大略省不同城市、农村和文化背景地区的5名产科医生、10名家庭医生、7名助产士和4名产前诊所护士使用了该表。3个月后,这些医疗服务提供者参加焦点小组讨论他们的经验。还对使用ALPHA表进行评估的部分孕妇就其经历进行了访谈。结果采用定性方法进行分析。
ALPHA表的最终版本将15个风险因素分为4类——家庭因素、产妇因素、药物滥用和家庭暴力——并针对每个询问领域提出了建议问题。医疗服务提供者一致报告称,该表帮助他们发现了新的且往往令人惊讶的信息,即使这些女性对他们来说很熟悉。将该表纳入实践通常是在一段时间的熟悉之后完成的。大多数提供者表示该表很有用,如果它成为标准护理的一部分,他们会继续使用。样本中的孕妇表示,他们重视这些询问,并且对这个过程感到自在,除非存在较大的文化障碍。
ALPHA表似乎是评估孕期心理社会健康的重要工具,并且易于融入实践。需要更多研究来量化所识别的风险数量和所使用的资源,以确定该表的可靠性和有效性,并最终评估其使用对产后结局的影响。