MacNamara A F, Brazil E, Evans P A
Accident and Emergency Department, Leicester Royal Infirmary NHS Trust.
J Accid Emerg Med. 1998 Sep;15(5):294-7. doi: 10.1136/emj.15.5.294.
To examine the use made of 24 hour access to computed tomography from an accident and emergency (A&E) department and to assess whether clear benefits for patients could be identified by having such a service.
Retrospective review of 176 cases where computed tomography was ordered by A&E staff of a large teaching hospital over a one year period.
53% of scans were done "out of hours"; 97% of scans performed (171/176) were studies of the brain. Three examinations were of the cervical spine and two were of the chest. 54% of head scans (93/171) were performed for either confirmed or suspected trauma with 46% (78/171) done for medical indications. Only 16% (11/71) of patients who had a head scan for acute trauma required transfer to the regional neurosurgical unit after consultation. Computed tomography was 100% sensitive in the diagnosis of sub-arachnoid haemorrhage. In cases where computed tomography was performed for coma of undetermined origin the pathology causing coma was identified on computed tomography in 50% of cases.
Computed tomography facilities allow comprehensive initial evaluation of the head injured patient and minimise hazardous and expensive transfer of these seriously ill patients. Experience shows that it is a vital tool in the initial differential diagnosis of the comatose patient and therefore must be available for use by senior and middle grade A&E staff on a 24 hour basis.
研究在急诊部门24小时使用计算机断层扫描的情况,并评估提供此项服务是否能明确给患者带来益处。
回顾性分析一家大型教学医院急诊工作人员在一年时间内开出的176例计算机断层扫描病例。
53%的扫描在“非工作时间”进行;所进行的扫描中97%(171/176)是脑部检查。3例为颈椎检查,2例为胸部检查。54%的头部扫描(93/171)是针对已确诊或疑似的创伤进行的,46%(78/171)是出于医疗指征进行的。在因急性创伤进行头部扫描的患者中,只有16%(11/71)在会诊后需要转至区域神经外科病房。计算机断层扫描对蛛网膜下腔出血的诊断敏感度为100%。在对病因不明的昏迷患者进行计算机断层扫描的病例中,50%在扫描中发现了导致昏迷的病变。
计算机断层扫描设备可对头外伤患者进行全面的初步评估,并最大限度减少这些重症患者危险且昂贵的转运。经验表明,它是昏迷患者初步鉴别诊断的重要工具,因此必须可供急诊中高级工作人员24小时使用。