Schuricht A L, Spitz F, Barbot D, Rosato F
Department of Surgery, Pennsylvania Hospital, Philadelphia 19107, USA.
Am Surg. 1998 Nov;64(11):1043-9.
The purpose of this study is to assess the feasibility, clinical tolerance, local control, and survival rates using a combined-modality treatment program of intraoperative radiation, chemotherapy, and external beam radiation for the management of patients with pancreatic cancer. One hundred eighty patients with biopsy-proven adenocarcinoma of the pancreas have been treated by a single surgical practice between 1979 and 1992. Of these, 105 had locally advanced but unresectable primary tumors (stages 2 and 3). All patients were treated with a program of multimodality therapy, including surgery, chemotherapy, and radiation therapy. Three groups were identified. Group I (33 patients) received intraoperative radiation therapy (IORT) as part of their treatment. Group II (43 patients) received intraoperative radiation in the form of iodine-125 (I-125) implantation. Group III (29 patients) received no intraoperative radiation. All three groups were comparably similar with respect to age at presentation, amount of preoperative weight loss, preoperative symptoms, and tumor location. Overall perioperative mortality was 4.8 per cent (five patients), with no difference between groups noted. Perioperative complications occurred in 32 (30.4%) of the 105 patients. Complications occurred in only 18.1 per cent of patients in Group I (IORT), compared with 39.5 per cent of Group II (I-125) patients (P < 0.01). Group III patients (no intraoperative radiation) experienced complications in 31.0 per cent of cases (P = 0.09 vs Group I). Actuarial survival was 18 months for Group I (IORT) versus 15 months for Group II (I-125). One- and 2-year actuarial survival rates were 60 and 17 per cent for patients in Group I (IORT) and 56 and 19 per cent for Group II (I-125). Actuarial local control rates for patients receiving IORT (Group I) was 70 per cent at 2 years. Patients with pancreatic cancer historically have poor survival and local control rates despite aggressive chemotherapy and radiation. The addition of intraoperative radiation to the combined modality management of pancreatic cancer offers markedly improved survival rates and local control with minimal morbidity for patients with unresectable disease. Intraoperative radiation in the form of IORT can be delivered with a significantly fewer complications than I-125 seed implantation.
本研究的目的是评估采用术中放疗、化疗及外照射联合治疗方案来治疗胰腺癌患者时的可行性、临床耐受性、局部控制情况及生存率。1979年至1992年间,一家外科诊所对180例经活检证实为胰腺腺癌的患者进行了治疗。其中,105例患者患有局部晚期但无法切除的原发性肿瘤(2期和3期)。所有患者均接受了包括手术、化疗和放疗在内的多模式治疗方案。确定了三组。第一组(33例患者)接受术中放疗(IORT)作为其治疗的一部分。第二组(43例患者)接受碘-125(I-125)植入形式的术中放疗。第三组(29例患者)未接受术中放疗。三组在就诊时的年龄、术前体重减轻量、术前症状及肿瘤位置方面具有可比性。围手术期总死亡率为4.8%(5例患者),各组之间未发现差异。105例患者中有32例(30.4%)发生围手术期并发症。第一组(IORT)患者中仅18.1%发生并发症,而第二组(I-125)患者中这一比例为39.5%(P<0.01)。第三组患者(未接受术中放疗)并发症发生率为31.0%(与第一组相比,P = 0.09)。第一组(IORT)的精算生存率为18个月,第二组(I-125)为15个月。第一组(IORT)患者的1年和2年精算生存率分别为60%和17%,第二组(I-125)为56%和19%。接受IORT(第一组)的患者2年精算局部控制率为70%。历史上,胰腺癌患者尽管接受了积极的化疗和放疗,但其生存率和局部控制率仍很低。在胰腺癌的联合治疗中加入术中放疗可显著提高无法切除疾病患者的生存率和局部控制率,且发病率最低。与I-125粒子植入相比,IORT形式的术中放疗并发症明显更少。