Gerszten P C
Department of Neurological Surgery, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Pennsylvania, USA.
Neurosurgery. 1998 Nov;43(5):1146-56. doi: 10.1097/00006123-199811000-00072.
The purpose of this article is to review the history of the medical outcomes movement as well as the methodologies used in outcomes research.
Outcomes research refers to a genre of clinical investigation that emphasizes the measurement of patient health outcomes, including the patient's symptoms, functional status, quality of life, satisfaction with treatment, and health care costs.
Outcomes research evolved from studies that demonstrated the presence of wide geographic variations in the practice of medicine and surgery. Such differences in utilization were unaccompanied by any discernible difference in patient outcomes. With escalating health care costs, there has been a growing interest in measuring the outcomes of medical intervention to determine the quality and appropriateness of medical care.
Outcomes may be measured both directly and indirectly, over differing periods of time, and with varying degrees of objectivity, reliability, and validity. Current research has focused on quality of life issues, which include the extent to which a patient's usual or expected physical, emotional, and social well-being have been affected by a medical condition or treatment. The true value of health care can be determined only by a systematic examination of patient outcomes. To accomplish this goal, methods are required that are relatively unfamiliar to many clinical researchers. Future clinical research should include patient-oriented outcome measures that would otherwise focus solely on physiological or anatomic outcomes. Such information will be essential in determining which medical and surgical treatment strategies should be abandoned and which will gain acceptance in the future.
本文旨在回顾医学结局运动的历史以及结局研究中所使用的方法。
结局研究是指一类临床研究,它强调对患者健康结局的测量,包括患者的症状、功能状态、生活质量、对治疗的满意度以及医疗保健成本。
结局研究源自一些研究,这些研究表明医学和外科手术实践中存在广泛的地域差异。这种使用上的差异并未伴随患者结局出现任何可察觉的差异。随着医疗保健成本的不断攀升,人们越来越关注测量医疗干预的结局,以确定医疗保健的质量和适宜性。
结局可以在不同时间段内,通过直接和间接的方式进行测量,且具有不同程度的客观性、可靠性和有效性。当前的研究聚焦于生活质量问题,其中包括患者的正常或预期的身体、情感和社会福祉受疾病或治疗影响的程度。医疗保健的真正价值只能通过对患者结局的系统考察来确定。为实现这一目标,需要许多临床研究人员相对不熟悉的方法。未来的临床研究应纳入以患者为导向的结局指标,否则这些研究可能仅关注生理或解剖学结局。此类信息对于确定哪些医学和外科治疗策略应被摒弃以及哪些策略将在未来获得认可至关重要。