Aktekin M, Erozgen C, Donmez L
Faculty of Medicine, Department of Public Health, Akdeniz University, Antalya, Turkey.
Public Health. 1998 Sep;112(5):323-6. doi: 10.1038/sj.ph.1900478.
A study examining the approach of pharmacies to diarrhoeal disease in childhood was carried out in Antalya, Turkey. A fictitious case history of a 10 month infant with an acute diarrhoea of three days duration, which was clinically identical with viral diarrhoea and accompanied by moderate dehydration was hypothesised. Following this, final semester students of the medical faculty posed as relatives of the infant and sought the advice of pharmacy attendants. The approach, to this hypothesised case, of all 214 pharmacies in the Antalya municipality district was examined. Most of the pharmacy attendants (57.7%) did not ask any questions to determine a differential diagnosis or establish the degree of dehydration. Only 21.6% of the pharmacy attendants recommended consulting a doctor or health centre, 6.5% recommended Oral Rehydration Solution (ORS) without giving an explanation about the amount needed or for how long it should be administered, 44.4% only dispensed a drug, 23.8% dispensed a drug with ORS and 3.7% recommended infant formula. Antidiarrhoeals were dispensed by 67.2% of the pharmacies and 14% gave antibiotics. Also 5.6% of the pharmacy attendants advised a reduction in the infant's fluid intake, 17.3% said that they could not give an opinion regarding breast feeding 19.2% advised stopping breast feeding and 7.0% did not know. All the pharmacies except the ones with the appropriate recommendation 'consult a doctor or a health centre' responded with advice given without hesitation although they did not intend to inspect or examine the infant. The approaches for acute diarrhoea of the pharmacies were determined as inappropriate and harmful.
在土耳其安塔利亚开展了一项关于药店对儿童腹泻病处理方式的研究。假设了一个虚构的病例,一名10个月大的婴儿,急性腹泻持续三天,临床症状与病毒性腹泻相同,并伴有中度脱水。随后,医学院最后一学期的学生假扮婴儿亲属,向药店工作人员寻求建议。对安塔利亚市辖区内的所有214家药店针对这一假设病例的处理方式进行了检查。大多数药店工作人员(57.7%)没有询问任何问题以确定鉴别诊断或判断脱水程度。只有21.6%的药店工作人员建议咨询医生或健康中心,6.5%的人推荐口服补液盐(ORS),但未说明所需剂量或服用时长,44.4%的人仅配药,23.8%的人配药并提供ORS,3.7%的人推荐婴儿配方奶粉。67.2%的药店配发止泻药,14%的药店给抗生素。此外,5.6%的药店工作人员建议减少婴儿的液体摄入量,17.3%的人表示无法就母乳喂养给出意见,19.2%的人建议停止母乳喂养,7.0%的人表示不知道。除了那些给出“咨询医生或健康中心”这一恰当建议的药店外,所有药店都毫不犹豫地给出了建议,尽管他们并未打算检查或查看婴儿。研究确定药店对急性腹泻的处理方式是不恰当且有害的。