Chenoweth L
Wesley Gardens Aged Care Centre, Belrose, NSW, Australia.
Nurse Educ Today. 1998 May;18(4):281-92. doi: 10.1016/s0260-6917(98)80045-2.
An exploratory study was conducted during 1995 to examine the degree to which critical thinking was encouraged in nursing education throughout New South Wales (NSW), Australia. The study identified whether a sample of graduate nurses and nurse educators at 12 faculties of nursing in NSW shared similar ideas about what critical thinking entails, the best ways in which to develop critical thinking processes and whether critical thinking is a reasonable way for nurses to achieve skilled and effective nursing interventions. The findings indicate that both nursing students and nurse educators favour the facilitation of critical thinking for nursing for very practical reasons. These refer to improving professional standards of practice, stimulating inquiry and promoting sound reasoning in practice, as well as contributing to personal and professional development. Study participants were found to favour a variety of teaching and learning strategies for critical thinking, and this finding is the focus for this discussion paper. The majority of participants stated that nurses would perhaps be better able to abstract principles of thinking from the specific contexts in which they are practised. Strategies found effective for nursing practice included a variety of approaches: direct learning of skills that contribute to critical thinking, such as analysis; infusion, or integration of critical thinking in all areas of learning; and learning to think critically within distinct disciplines of thought. Analysis of the findings, therefore, suggests that critical thinking is thought to be an important component of nursing practice and that in nursing it is a complex activity, requiring a combination of dispositions, abilities and approaches that can be developed by drawing on a range of learning strategies.
1995年开展了一项探索性研究,以考察澳大利亚新南威尔士州(NSW)护理教育中鼓励批判性思维的程度。该研究确定了新南威尔士州12所护理学院的一组毕业护士和护理教育工作者对于批判性思维的内涵、培养批判性思维过程的最佳方法以及批判性思维是否是护士实现熟练且有效的护理干预的合理方式是否持有相似观点。研究结果表明,出于非常实际的原因,护理专业学生和护理教育工作者都倾向于在护理工作中促进批判性思维。这些原因包括提高专业实践标准、激发探究精神以及促进实践中的合理推理,还有助于个人和职业发展。研究发现,参与者倾向于采用多种批判性思维的教学和学习策略,这一发现是本讨论文件的重点。大多数参与者表示,护士或许能更好地从实践的具体情境中提炼思维原则。对护理实践有效的策略包括多种方法:直接学习有助于批判性思维的技能,如分析;将批判性思维融入或整合到所有学习领域;以及在不同的思维学科中学会批判性思考。因此,对研究结果的分析表明,批判性思维被认为是护理实践的一个重要组成部分,并且在护理领域它是一项复杂的活动,需要通过运用一系列学习策略来培养多种性格特征、能力和方法的组合。