Carney M W, Sheffield B F
Br J Psychiatry. 1976 Nov;129:476-81. doi: 10.1192/bjp.129.5.476.
122 Schizophrenic patients treated with injections of fluphenazine ethanate, 97 with fluphenazine decanoate and 199 with flupenthixol decanoate were followed up for mean times of 41, 33 and 21 months respectively. Their progress was compared by examining reasons for discontinuing injections and outcome in three separate groups defined according to first preparation given; relating the events causing patients to discontinue injections or be readmitted to patient-months spent on each drug; and analysing reasons for inter-drug transfers 43 per cent, 24 per cent and 23 per cent respectively of these three groups of patients discontinued the injections. Severe extrapyramidal effects were most frequent with fluphenazine ethanate, intermediate with fluphenazine decanote, and least frequent frequent with flupenthixol. Lack of cooperation was rather more frequent with flupenthixol than with the other drugs. Severe depression occurred with all three. More patients on fluphenazine injections were transferred for any reason to flupenthixol than vice-versa. A case of 'irreversible' movement disorder was seen with each preparation. It is suggested that current maintenance doses of flupenthixol decanoate are too low.
对122例接受乙磺酸氟奋乃静注射治疗的精神分裂症患者、97例接受癸酸氟奋乃静治疗的患者以及199例接受癸酸氟哌噻吨治疗的患者分别进行了平均41个月、33个月和21个月的随访。通过检查停药原因以及在根据首次使用的制剂划分的三个不同组中的结局来比较他们的进展情况;将导致患者停药或再次入院的事件与每种药物使用的患者月数相关联;并分析换药原因。这三组患者分别有43%、24%和23%停止了注射。严重锥体外系反应在乙磺酸氟奋乃静治疗时最为常见,在癸酸氟奋乃静治疗时次之,在癸酸氟哌噻吨治疗时最少见。氟哌噻吨治疗时患者不合作的情况比其他药物更为常见。三种药物治疗时均出现了严重抑郁。因任何原因从氟奋乃静注射换药至氟哌噻吨的患者比反向换药的患者更多。每种制剂均出现了1例“不可逆”运动障碍病例。提示目前癸酸氟哌噻吨的维持剂量过低。