Ellman R, Maxwell C, Finch R, Shayo D
Amani Medical Research Centre, Tanga, Tanzania.
Ann Trop Med Parasitol. 1998 Oct;92(7):741-53. doi: 10.1080/00034989858989.
Parallel monthly surveys of children aged 6-71 months were conducted in the Muheza district of Tanzania. The aim was to compare highland villages, where the mean, annual entomological inoculation rate (EIR) for malaria is 34 and mean annual prevalences of parasitaemia range from 33%-76%, with culturally similar villages of the lowlands, where the mean EIR is 405 and prevalences of parasitaemia range from 80%-84%. The total survey population could be divided into six geographical subgroups, which can be arranged in order of increasing prevalence of parasitaemia. The prevalences of dense parasitaemia, of febrile malaria, and of anaemia all increased in the same order across this series of groups, the trends being statistically significant. The results of previous studies have indicated a paradoxical effect whereby children in regions with a lower exposure to malarial infection suffer, in the long term, a higher incidence of severe attacks of malaria. In the present study there was no sign of any such paradoxical inverse relationship between the level of exposure and the prevalence of malarial illness or anaemia. However, child mortality rates are similar in the highlands and lowlands, as are the median ages of children admitted to hospital. Overall, the present findings indicate that, for the populations studied, an artificial reduction in EIR would be beneficial, even in the long term, with regard to the chronic effects of malaria. This does not necessarily conflict with previous studies reporting opposite conclusions with regard to the incidence of severe,acute effects.
在坦桑尼亚的穆赫扎区对6至71个月大的儿童进行了每月一次的平行调查。目的是比较高地村庄和低地文化相似的村庄,高地村庄疟疾的平均年度昆虫学接种率(EIR)为34,寄生虫血症的平均年度患病率在33%-76%之间,而低地村庄的平均EIR为405,寄生虫血症的患病率在80%-84%之间。总调查人群可分为六个地理亚组,这些亚组可按寄生虫血症患病率递增的顺序排列。在这一系列组中,高密度寄生虫血症、发热性疟疾和贫血的患病率均以相同顺序增加,这些趋势具有统计学意义。先前研究的结果表明存在一种矛盾效应,即长期来看,疟疾感染暴露较低地区的儿童患严重疟疾发作的发生率更高。在本研究中,暴露水平与疟疾疾病或贫血患病率之间没有任何这种矛盾的反比关系迹象。然而,高地和低地的儿童死亡率相似,住院儿童的年龄中位数也相似。总体而言,目前的研究结果表明,对于所研究的人群,即使从长期来看,人为降低EIR对于疟疾的慢性影响也是有益的。这不一定与先前关于严重急性影响发生率报告相反结论的研究相冲突。