LoBue P A, Cass R, Lobo D, Moser K, Catanzaro A
Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, University of California, San Diego Medical Center, 92103-8374, USA.
Chest. 1999 Jan;115(1):218-23. doi: 10.1378/chest.115.1.218.
To describe our experience with novel supervised housing programs developed to aid in the treatment of tuberculosis (TB) in homeless individuals, including a preliminary analysis of their effectiveness and estimate of potential cost savings.
Retrospective chart review.
A county TB control program.
The San Diego County TB Control Program's computer database was used to identify homeless individuals placed in one of two supervised housing programs for treatment of TB [Young Men's Christian Association (YMCA), for noninfectious patients, or Bissell House, for infectious patients]. Charts for all these patients were reviewed and information regarding their demographics, underlying medical conditions, therapy, microbiologic markers of response to therapy, hospitalizations, and participation in supervised housing programs was recorded.
The sputum culture conversion and treatment completion rates for those housed in the YMCA were 100 and 84.6%, respectively. Of the patients in the Bissell House program, 100% had converted their smear and culture. In addition, all patients in this program completed an adequate course of supervised therapy. These rates of microbiologic conversion and treatment completion compare favorably with historical data from San Diego County and other locations. Estimated cost savings for placing medically stable infectious patients in the Bissell House for respiratory isolation and supervised treatment were estimated to be $27,034 per patient.
Use of supervised housing to aid in treatment of TB in the homeless appears to be effective and results in substantial cost savings. A larger multicenter study should be considered to confirm these findings and better quantify the cost-effectiveness of such programs.
描述我们在为帮助无家可归者治疗结核病(TB)而开发的新型监督性住房项目方面的经验,包括对其有效性的初步分析以及对潜在成本节约的估计。
回顾性病历审查。
一个县的结核病控制项目。
利用圣地亚哥县结核病控制项目的计算机数据库,识别被安置在两个监督性住房项目之一中接受结核病治疗的无家可归者[基督教青年会(YMCA),用于非传染性患者;比塞尔之家,用于传染性患者]。对所有这些患者的病历进行审查,并记录有关他们的人口统计学信息、基础医疗状况、治疗、治疗反应的微生物学指标、住院情况以及参与监督性住房项目的信息。
入住基督教青年会的患者痰培养转阴率和治疗完成率分别为100%和84.6%。在比塞尔之家项目的患者中,100%的患者涂片和培养均已转阴。此外,该项目的所有患者均完成了足够疗程的监督治疗。这些微生物学转阴率和治疗完成率与圣地亚哥县及其他地区的历史数据相比更具优势。将病情稳定的传染性患者安置在比塞尔之家进行呼吸道隔离和监督治疗,估计每位患者可节省成本27,034美元。
使用监督性住房来帮助无家可归者治疗结核病似乎是有效的,并且能大幅节省成本。应考虑开展一项更大规模的多中心研究来证实这些发现,并更好地量化此类项目的成本效益。