Silva Everton Nunes, Pereira Ana Carolina Esteves da Silva, de Araújo Wildo Navegantes, Elias Flávia Tavares Silva
Universidade de Brasília, Brasília, DF, Brazil.
Oswaldo Cruz Foundation, Oswaldo Cruz Foundation, Brasília, DF, Brazil.
Rev Panam Salud Publica. 2018 Mar 30;42:e40. doi: 10.26633/RPSP.2018.40. eCollection 2018.
To analyze economic evaluations of interventions related to tuberculosis (TB) diagnostics/screening, treatment, and prevention in homeless people.
A systematic review was conducted. The eligibility criteria were original studies reporting economic evaluation results. The search was not restricted by language or year. A critical appraisal approach was used.
A total of 142 studies were identified, including five research articles (three full economic evaluations and two partial) that were selected for the final review. Most of the studies were conducted in the United States, adopted a public health perspective, and analyzed active TB. Interventions related to diagnostics/screening (the use of interferon-gamma release assay (IGRA) and mobile screening units), treatment (incentives for continuing treatment, and housing programs), and prevention (with the Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccine) were identified.
No high-quality data were found on cost-effectiveness of interventions on TB diagnostics/screening, treatment, or prevention in homeless people. However, active searching for cases via mobile screening, and financial incentives, could help increase treatment adherence, and the use of IGRA helps boost detection. TB in homeless people is neglected worldwide, especially in developing countries, where this disease tends to afflict more people made vulnerable by their precarious living conditions. Public funding mechanisms should be created to develop cross-sectoral actions targeting homeless people, as the complex dynamics of this group tend to hamper prevention and diagnosis of TB and the completion of TB treatment.
分析针对无家可归者结核病诊断/筛查、治疗及预防相关干预措施的经济学评价。
进行了一项系统综述。纳入标准为报告经济学评价结果的原始研究。检索不受语言或年份限制。采用了批判性评价方法。
共识别出142项研究,其中5篇研究文章(3篇完整的经济学评价和2篇部分评价)被选入最终综述。大多数研究在美国开展,采用公共卫生视角,且分析的是活动性结核病。识别出了与诊断/筛查(使用γ-干扰素释放试验(IGRA)和移动筛查单位)、治疗(持续治疗激励措施及住房项目)及预防(使用卡介苗(BCG)疫苗)相关的干预措施。
未发现关于无家可归者结核病诊断/筛查、治疗或预防干预措施成本效益的高质量数据。然而,通过移动筛查积极寻找病例以及提供经济激励措施,有助于提高治疗依从性,且使用IGRA有助于提高检出率。无家可归者中的结核病在全球范围内被忽视,尤其是在发展中国家,在这些国家,这种疾病往往更容易折磨因生活条件不稳定而变得脆弱的人群。应建立公共资金机制,以开展针对无家可归者的跨部门行动,因为该群体的复杂动态情况往往会阻碍结核病的预防、诊断及治疗的完成。