Mearin F, Balboa A, Zárate N, Cucala M, Malagelada J R
Digestive System Research Unit, Hospital General Universitari Vall d'Hebron, Barcelona, Spain.
Am J Gastroenterol. 1999 Jan;94(1):116-25. doi: 10.1111/j.1572-0241.1999.00781.x.
OBJECTIVE: Therapeutic trials in functional dyspepsia consistently show a substantial placebo response, but there is no clear explanation for such an effect. Our aim was to evaluate symptomatic, gastrointestinal motor, and gastric sensorial responses to placebo treatment in patients with chronic and severe functional dyspepsia who were part of a therapeutic trial. METHODS: Thirty patients were treated during 8 wk with placebo (white-colored 8-mm tablets containing cellulose) by mouth, 20 min before breakfast, lunch, and dinner. We quantified the symptomatic response to placebo as a change in global health status, and also as a change in the individual and combined (global symptom index) of a five-symptom complex: upper abdominal pain, nausea, vomiting, bloating/fullness, and early satiety. Gastroduodenal motility, during fasting and postprandially, was evaluated by manometry in all patients pretreatment and in 17 patients posttreatment. Gastric sensitivity to distension was evaluated in 18 patients pretreatment and in five patients posttreatment (all of them clinical responders). RESULTS: Placebo treatment produced a striking symptomatic improvement; by 8 wk 80% of the patients reported an improved global health status and their global symptom index markedly decreased (23.9+/-1.3 pretreatment vs 9.1+/-1.2; p < 0.05). Placebo increased the number of gastric phases III starting in the antrum during the fasting period (1.1+/-0.1 vs 1.6+/-0.2; p < 0.05). As a group, no significant changes in postprandial gastroduodenal motility were observed after placebo treatment. However, after placebo a significant improvement in the antral motility index (MI) was observed in the subset of patients with antral hypomotility (MI pretreatment: 7.9+/-1.0; MI posttreatment: 11.7+/-0.4; p < 0.05). Before placebo treatment, patients with functional dyspepsia showed increased sensitivity to stepwise distension of the stomach relative to healthy individuals. After 8 wk of placebo treatment sensitivity to distension remained unchanged, even though patients' clinical status was markedly improved. CONCLUSION: In patients with functional dyspepsia, the symptomatic response to placebo is substantial. Some significant changes were also observed in gastric motility: increase in the gastric phase III number as well as in the postprandial antral motility index in those with hypomotility pretreatment. Remarkably, however, clinical improvement seems to occur independently of detectable changes in gastroduodenal motor activity or gastric hypersensitivity to distension.
目的:功能性消化不良的治疗试验一直显示出显著的安慰剂反应,但对于这种效应尚无明确解释。我们的目的是评估参与一项治疗试验的慢性重度功能性消化不良患者对安慰剂治疗的症状、胃肠动力及胃感觉反应。 方法:30例患者在早餐、午餐和晚餐前20分钟口服安慰剂(含纤维素的白色8毫米片剂),持续8周。我们将对安慰剂的症状反应量化为整体健康状况的变化,以及一个五症状复合体(上腹部疼痛、恶心、呕吐、腹胀/饱胀感和早饱)的个体及综合(整体症状指数)变化。在所有患者治疗前及17例患者治疗后通过测压法评估空腹及餐后的胃十二指肠动力。在18例患者治疗前及5例患者治疗后(均为临床反应者)评估胃对扩张的敏感性。 结果:安慰剂治疗带来了显著的症状改善;至8周时,80%的患者报告整体健康状况有所改善,其整体症状指数显著下降(治疗前23.9±1.3 vs治疗后9.1±1.2;p<0.05)。安慰剂增加了空腹期始于胃窦的胃Ⅲ期次数(1.1±0.1 vs 1.6±0.2;p<0.05)。作为一个整体,安慰剂治疗后餐后胃十二指肠动力未观察到显著变化。然而,安慰剂治疗后,胃窦动力低下亚组患者的胃窦动力指数(MI)有显著改善(治疗前MI:7.9±1.0;治疗后MI:11.7±0.4;p<0.05)。在安慰剂治疗前,功能性消化不良患者相对于健康个体对胃的逐步扩张显示出更高的敏感性。安慰剂治疗8周后,尽管患者的临床状况显著改善,但对扩张的敏感性仍未改变。 结论:在功能性消化不良患者中,对安慰剂的症状反应显著。在胃动力方面也观察到了一些显著变化:胃Ⅲ期次数增加,以及治疗前动力低下患者的餐后胃窦动力指数增加。然而,值得注意的是,临床改善似乎独立于胃十二指肠运动活动或胃对扩张的高敏感性的可检测变化而发生。
Am J Gastroenterol. 1999-1
Dtsch Z Verdau Stoffwechselkr. 1988
Am J Gastroenterol. 1999-1
Neurogastroenterol Motil. 2008-6
Aliment Pharmacol Ther. 2007-11-15
Front Psychiatry. 2020-8-25
Dig Dis Sci. 2013-8-11
Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2013-4-30
J Neurogastroenterol Motil. 2012-7-10
Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2011-6-27
Perspect Biol Med. 2009
World J Gastroenterol. 2007-7-7