Ely J W, Levy B T, Hartz A
Department of Family Medicine, University of Iowa College of Medicine, USA.
J Fam Pract. 1999 Feb;48(2):135-9.
When faced with questions about patient care, family physicians usually turn to books in their personal libraries for the answers. The resources in these libraries have not been adequately characterized.
We recorded the titles of all medical books in the personal libraries of 103 randomly selected family physicians in eastern Iowa. We also noted all clinical information that was posted on walls, bulletin boards, refrigerators, and so forth. Participants were asked to describe their use of other resources such as computers, MEDLINE, reprint files, and "peripheral brains" (personal notebooks of clinical information). For each physician, we recorded how often the resources were used to answer clinical questions during 2 half-day observation periods.
The 103 participants owned a total of 5794 medical books, with 2836 different titles. Each physician kept an average of 56 books in the office. Prescribing references (especially the Physicians' Desk Reference) were most common (owned by 100% of the participants), followed by books on general internal medicine (99%), adult infectious disease (89%), and general pediatrics (83%). Books used to answer clinical questions were more likely to be up to date (copyright date within 5 years) than unused books (74% vs 27%, P <.001). Items posted on walls included drug dosage charts and pediatric immunization schedules. Only 26% of the physicians had computers in their offices.
Drug-prescribing textbooks were the most common type of book in family physicians' offices, followed by books on general internal medicine and adult infectious diseases. Although many books were relatively old, those used to answer clinical questions were generally current.
面对有关患者护理的问题时,家庭医生通常会查阅其个人藏书来寻找答案。这些藏书中的资源尚未得到充分描述。
我们记录了爱荷华州东部随机选取的103位家庭医生个人藏书中所有医学书籍的书名。我们还记录了张贴在墙上、公告栏、冰箱等上面的所有临床信息。参与者被要求描述他们对其他资源的使用情况,如计算机、医学在线数据库(MEDLINE)、重印文件以及“外部大脑”(临床信息的个人笔记本)。对于每位医生,我们记录了在两个半天的观察期内这些资源用于回答临床问题的频率。
103名参与者共拥有5794本医学书籍,有2836个不同的书名。每位医生办公室平均存放56本书。处方参考书籍(尤其是《医师案头参考手册》)最为常见(100%的参与者拥有),其次是普通内科书籍(99%)、成人传染病书籍(89%)和普通儿科书籍(83%)。用于回答临床问题的书籍比未使用的书籍更有可能是最新的(版权日期在5年内)(74%对27%,P<.001)。张贴在墙上的物品包括药物剂量表和儿童免疫接种时间表。只有26%的医生办公室配备了计算机。
药物处方教科书是家庭医生办公室最常见的书籍类型,其次是普通内科和成人传染病方面的书籍。尽管许多书籍相对较旧,但用于回答临床问题的书籍通常是最新的。