Smyth E T, Barr J G, O'Neill C A, Hogg G M
Department of Bacteriology, Royal Hospitals Trust, Belfast, Northern Ireland.
Pharmacoeconomics. 1995 Dec;8(6):541-50. doi: 10.2165/00019053-199508060-00008.
The aim of this study was to compare the hidden costs, and their impact on total antibiotic costs, of ceftriaxone therapy with those of cefotaxime, ceftazidime and cefuroxime in nosocomial infection. The total antibiotic costs of 7-day standard courses of the 4 cephalosporins were compared. The costs were divided into 3 parts: (i) the cost of the drug itself; (ii) the preparation and administration (labour) costs; and (iii) the consumables and waste costs. The latter 2 costs together comprised the hidden cost of an antibiotic course. Hidden costs were higher for cefotaxime, ceftazidime and cefuroxime, which are normally administered 3 times a day, than for ceftriaxone, which is administered once daily. The percentage contribution of hidden costs to total antibiotic costs increased with decreasing antibiotic cost, and were lower with higher dosages of all antibiotics. With cefotaxime, ceftazidime and cefuroxime, and with ceftriaxone at the lower dosage given by bolus intravenous (IV) injection, the labour component of hidden costs exceeded the consumables/waste component. However, when costs were calculated for ceftriaxone administered at the higher dosage by IV infusion, the costs of consumables and waste were greater than the labour costs. Ceftriaxone had the lowest hidden costs of all the antibiotics studied. The total antibiotic cost of low dosage ceftriaxone (1 g per dose) was comparable with that of cefuroxime, and was substantially less than the costs of cefotaxime and ceftazidime. At the high ceftriaxone dosage (2g per dose), the total antibiotic cost of cefuroxime was less than that of ceftriaxone; however, the total antibiotic cost of ceftriaxone remained substantially less than that of cefotaxime or ceftazidime.
本研究旨在比较头孢曲松与头孢噻肟、头孢他啶和头孢呋辛治疗医院感染时的隐性成本及其对总抗生素成本的影响。比较了4种头孢菌素7天标准疗程的总抗生素成本。成本分为3部分:(i)药物本身的成本;(ii)配制和给药(人工)成本;(iii)耗材和废弃物成本。后两项成本共同构成抗生素疗程的隐性成本。头孢噻肟、头孢他啶和头孢呋辛通常每日给药3次,其隐性成本高于每日给药1次的头孢曲松。隐性成本占总抗生素成本的百分比随抗生素成本降低而增加,且所有抗生素剂量越高该百分比越低。对于头孢噻肟、头孢他啶和头孢呋辛以及静脉推注较低剂量的头孢曲松,隐性成本中的人工部分超过耗材/废弃物部分。然而,当计算静脉滴注较高剂量头孢曲松的成本时,耗材和废弃物成本高于人工成本。在所有研究的抗生素中,头孢曲松的隐性成本最低。低剂量头孢曲松(每剂1g)的总抗生素成本与头孢呋辛相当,且大幅低于头孢噻肟和头孢他啶的成本。在头孢曲松高剂量(每剂2g)时,头孢呋辛的总抗生素成本低于头孢曲松;然而,头孢曲松的总抗生素成本仍大幅低于头孢噻肟或头孢他啶。