Hope J K, Byrne J V, Molyneux A J
Department of Neuroradiology, Radcliffe Infirmary, Oxford, England.
AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 1999 Mar;20(3):391-9.
Coil embolization of berry aneurysms is a relatively new treatment whose long-term efficacy has yet to be established. The purpose of this study was, first, to attempt to identify factors that might be important in predicting success both at the time of treatment and at the time of follow-up angiography, and, second, to study changes in the aneurysm between treatment and follow-up to determine the frequency of these changes.
The pretreatment, posttreatment, and follow-up angiograms of the first 63 aneurysms (in 58 patients) treated at our institution between June 1992 and April 1995 were analyzed, and the percentage of occlusion of each aneurysm was calculated. The size of any rest was noted for the posttreatment and follow-up angiograms. Treatment success was defined as a residue of less than 2 mm. Aneurysms were said to have changed if the percentage of occlusion had altered by more than 2.5% or if the difference in rest size was greater than 0.25 mm. Possible factors influencing primary and follow-up success rates were correlated against these calculations.
Success rates at treatment and follow-up were 71% and 65%, respectively. No change occurred in 41% of aneurysms, and 20% had a decrease in size of the residue. Twenty-eight percent had coil compaction, and 11% had aneurysmal growth. Neck size was the only significant variable in primary treatment success. Success at follow-up correlated significantly with neck size, initial treatment success, vasospasm at the time of treatment, and clinical presentation.
Best long-term angiographic results are obtained when the primary treatment is successful, when the aneurysm is small and narrow-necked, when the acutely ruptured aneurysm is treated within 15 days of ictus, and with anterior communicating and basilar-tip aneurysms.
颅内动脉瘤的弹簧圈栓塞术是一种相对较新的治疗方法,其长期疗效尚未确立。本研究的目的,一是试图确定在治疗时及随访血管造影时可能对预测成功至关重要的因素,二是研究治疗与随访期间动脉瘤的变化,以确定这些变化的频率。
分析了1992年6月至1995年4月在本机构治疗的前63例动脉瘤(58例患者)的治疗前、治疗后及随访血管造影,并计算每个动脉瘤的闭塞百分比。记录治疗后及随访血管造影中任何残留部分的大小。治疗成功定义为残留小于2mm。如果闭塞百分比改变超过2.5%或残留大小差异大于0.25mm,则认为动脉瘤发生了变化。将可能影响初次治疗和随访成功率的因素与这些计算结果进行相关性分析。
治疗时和随访时的成功率分别为71%和65%。41%的动脉瘤没有变化,20%的动脉瘤残留大小减小。28%的动脉瘤有弹簧圈压缩,11%的动脉瘤有瘤体增大。瘤颈大小是初次治疗成功的唯一显著变量。随访成功与瘤颈大小、初始治疗成功、治疗时的血管痉挛及临床表现显著相关。
当初次治疗成功、动脉瘤小且瘤颈窄、急性破裂动脉瘤在发病后15天内接受治疗以及治疗前交通动脉瘤和基底动脉尖动脉瘤时,可获得最佳的长期血管造影结果。