Konradsen F, Steele P, Perera D, van der Hoek W, Amerasinghe P H, Amerasinghe F P
International Irrigation Management Institute, Colombo, Sri Lanka.
Bull World Health Organ. 1999;77(4):301-9.
The study provides estimates of the cost of various malaria control measures in an area of North-Central Province of Sri Lanka where the disease is endemic. We assumed that each measure was equally effective. In these terms, impregnating privately purchased bednets with insecticide was estimated to cost Rs 48 (US(40.87) per individual protected per year, less than half the cost of spraying houses with residual insecticides. Larviciding of vector breeding sites and especially the elimination of breeding habitats by flushing streams through seasonal release of water from upstream reservoirs was estimated to be cheaper than other preventive measures (Rs 27 (US$ 0.49) and Rs 13 (US$ 0.24) per individual protected, respectively). Inclusion of both operational and capital costs of treatment indicates that the most cost-effective intervention for the government was a centrally located hospital with a relatively large catchment area (Rs 71 (US$ 1.29) per malaria case treated). Mobile clinics (Rs 153 (US$ 2.78) per malaria case treated) and a village treatment centre (Rs 112 (US$ 2.04)) per malaria case treated) were more expensive options for the government, but were considerably cheaper for households than the traditional hospital facilities. This information can guide health planners and government decision-makers in choosing the most appropriate combination of curative and preventive measures to control malaria. However, the option that is cheapest for the government may not be so for the householders, and further studies are needed to estimate the effectiveness of the various preventive measures.
该研究估算了斯里兰卡中北部省某疟疾流行地区各种疟疾控制措施的成本。我们假定每种措施的效果相同。据此估算,用杀虫剂浸渍私人购买的蚊帐,每人每年的成本为48卢比(0.4087美元),不到用残留杀虫剂喷洒房屋成本的一半。对病媒滋生地进行杀幼虫处理,特别是通过季节性从上游水库放水冲刷溪流来消除滋生地,估计比其他预防措施成本更低(每人每年分别为27卢比(0.49美元)和13卢比(0.24美元))。纳入治疗的运营成本和资本成本表明,对政府而言,最具成本效益的干预措施是一家位于中心位置、集水区相对较大的医院(每治疗一例疟疾病例成本为71卢比(1.29美元))。流动诊所(每治疗一例疟疾病例成本为153卢比(2.78美元))和乡村治疗中心(每治疗一例疟疾病例成本为112卢比(2.04美元))对政府来说成本更高,但对家庭来说比传统医院设施便宜得多。这些信息可指导卫生规划者和政府决策者选择控制疟疾的治疗和预防措施的最合适组合。然而,对政府来说最便宜的选择对家庭来说可能并非如此,还需要进一步研究来估算各种预防措施的效果。