Mathalon D H, Ford J M, Pfefferbaum A
Department of Psychiatry, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California, USA.
Biol Psychiatry. 2000 Mar 1;47(5):434-49. doi: 10.1016/s0006-3223(99)00277-2.
The P300 component of the auditory event-related brain potential (ERP) is consistently reduced in schizophrenia. Longitudinal data are examined to determine whether P300 amplitude is a trait marker of schizophrenia or a state marker tracking clinical fluctuations over time.
Schizophrenic men (DSM-III-R) (n = 36) received ERP and the Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale (BPRS) assessments on multiple occasions, at varying intervals, under varying medication states. Automatically elicited auditory P3a and effortfully elicited auditory and visual P3b amplitudes were assessed. Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale scores were regressed on P300 amplitude within patients using both multiple regression models and nonparametric analyses of individual patient slopes. Event related brain potentials in patients were compared to ERPs from 34 age-matched control men, and stability of P300 over time was estimated with intraclass correlations.
P300 amplitude, regardless of elicitation method or sensory modality, tracked BPRS Total and positive symptom scores over time, decreasing with symptom exacerbations and increasing with improvements. In addition, effortful auditory and visual P3b amplitudes tracked negative symptoms, and automatic auditory P3a tracked depression-anxiety symptoms. When analyses were limited to unmedicated occasions, auditory P3a and P3b persisted in tracking BPRS Total scores, with additional tracking of positive symptoms by P3b and mood symptoms by P3a. Mean auditory and visual P3bs, averaged over all measurement occasions for each individual, were inversely related to mean negative symptoms. Auditory P3a and P3b, but not visual P3b, amplitudes were smaller in patients than control subjects, even when patients were least symptomatic. P300 amplitudes showed high test-retest reliability in control subjects and patients and moderate stability over time in patients.
Auditory, and possibly visual, P300 amplitudes track fluctuations in clinical state, but only auditory P300 amplitude is a trait marker of schizophrenia.
精神分裂症患者听觉事件相关脑电位(ERP)中的P300成分持续降低。本研究通过纵向数据来确定P300波幅是精神分裂症的特质标记还是随时间追踪临床波动的状态标记。
36名符合《精神疾病诊断与统计手册第三版修订版》(DSM-III-R)的男性精神分裂症患者在不同的用药状态下,于不同时间间隔多次接受ERP和简明精神病评定量表(BPRS)评估。评估自动诱发的听觉P3a以及通过努力诱发的听觉和视觉P3b波幅。使用多元回归模型和个体患者斜率的非参数分析,在患者中对BPRS评分与P300波幅进行回归分析。将患者的事件相关脑电位与34名年龄匹配的对照男性的ERP进行比较,并使用组内相关系数估计P300随时间的稳定性。
无论诱发方法或感觉模态如何,P300波幅均随时间追踪BPRS总分和阳性症状评分,随症状加重而降低,随症状改善而升高。此外,通过努力诱发的听觉和视觉P3b波幅追踪阴性症状,自动诱发的听觉P3a追踪抑郁焦虑症状。当分析仅限于未用药的情况时,听觉P3a和P3b仍可追踪BPRS总分,P3b还可追踪阳性症状,P3a可追踪情绪症状。对每个个体所有测量次数的平均听觉和视觉P3b进行平均后,与平均阴性症状呈负相关。即使在患者症状最轻时,其听觉P3a和P3b波幅(而非视觉P3b波幅)也比对照受试者小。P300波幅在对照受试者和患者中显示出较高的重测信度,在患者中随时间具有中等稳定性。
听觉P300波幅,可能还有视觉P300波幅,可追踪临床状态的波动,但只有听觉P300波幅是精神分裂症的特质标记。