Schlesinger M, Kayhty H, Levy R, Bibi C, Meydan N, Levy J
Department of Pediatrics and Immunology, Barzilai Medical Centre, Ashkelon, Israel.
J Clin Immunol. 2000 Jan;20(1):46-53. doi: 10.1023/a:1006642611069.
Seven individuals with late complement component (LCC) deficiency and seven control subjects were vaccinated with tetravalent meningococcal vaccine. The response to vaccination was evaluated by measuring the antibody titer and the phagocyte killing of the bacteria, before, 5-7 weeks, and 12-14 months after vaccination. Prior to vaccination, no phagocytic killing and a low titer of antibody was found in the LCC-deficient group and a low killing (mean of 40-58%, according to the serogroup) in normal controls. The phagocytic killing increased significantly 5-7 weeks after vaccination. However, while in normal controls the phagocytic killing was close to 100% after 5-7 weeks and decreased only slightly during the first year, the mean killing of the various meningococcal subgroups in LCC-deficient individuals was 70-89% and dropped to only 53-71% one year after vaccination. Six weeks after vaccination the mean antimeningococcal antibody titer increased similarly in the sera of LCC-deficient patients and controls. One year after vaccination the controls maintained the high concentration, while the LCC-deficient patients had tendency toward a decrease. In addition, the interpersonal variability of the antibody concentration, both in LCC-deficient individuals and in normal controls, was much higher than the phagocytic killing, with only a very mild increase in some individuals. Thus, it is possible that in spite of adequate increase of antimeningococcal antibody titer after vaccination of LCC-deficient individuals their immunity against the bacteria may not be optimal. Our data show also that phagocytic killing of meningococci is probably a more consistent assay than antibody titer levels for antimeningococcal immunity, especially in LCC-deficient patients.
7名晚期补体成分(LCC)缺陷个体和7名对照受试者接种了四价脑膜炎球菌疫苗。通过在接种前、接种后5 - 7周以及12 - 14个月测量抗体滴度和细菌的吞噬细胞杀伤作用来评估疫苗接种反应。接种前,LCC缺陷组未发现吞噬细胞杀伤作用且抗体滴度较低,正常对照组的杀伤作用较低(根据血清群,平均值为40% - 58%)。接种后5 - 7周吞噬细胞杀伤作用显著增加。然而,虽然在正常对照组中,5 - 7周后吞噬细胞杀伤作用接近100%,且在第一年仅略有下降,但LCC缺陷个体中各种脑膜炎球菌亚组的平均杀伤作用在接种后为70% - 89%,一年后仅降至53% - 71%。接种后六周,LCC缺陷患者和对照组血清中的平均抗脑膜炎球菌抗体滴度同样升高。接种一年后,对照组维持高浓度,而LCC缺陷患者有下降趋势。此外,LCC缺陷个体和正常对照组中抗体浓度的个体间差异均远高于吞噬细胞杀伤作用,仅部分个体有非常轻微的增加。因此,尽管LCC缺陷个体接种疫苗后抗脑膜炎球菌抗体滴度有足够升高,但他们对细菌的免疫力可能并非最佳。我们的数据还表明,对于抗脑膜炎球菌免疫力,尤其是在LCC缺陷患者中,脑膜炎球菌的吞噬细胞杀伤作用可能是比抗体滴度水平更可靠的检测方法。