Abramovitz B A, Birch L L
Graduate Program in Nutrition, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park 16802, USA.
J Am Diet Assoc. 2000 Oct;100(10):1157-63. doi: 10.1016/S0002-8223(00)00339-4.
To explore 5-year-old girls' ideas, concepts, and beliefs about dieting.
Girls were asked to define dieting, to describe the behaviors dieting comprised, and were queried about links between dieting, weight control, and body shape. Parents completed questionnaires addressing family health history, demographics, and issues related to food, dieting, and weight control.
SUBJECTS/SETTING: Participants were 197 girls aged 5 years and their parents. All girls lived with both biological parents, and were without food allergies or chronic medical problems.
For 5 open-ended questions related to dieting, girls were categorized as either having or not having ideas about dieting. These ideas, concepts, and beliefs were categorized, and logistic regression examined predictors of girls' ideas about dieting.
Depending on the question, from 34% to 65% of girls aged 5 years had ideas about dieting. Compared to girls whose mothers did not diet, girls whose mothers reported current or recent dieting were more than twice as likely to have ideas about dieting, suggesting that mothers' dieting behavior is a source of young girls' ideas, concepts, and beliefs about dieting. Among mothers, more than 90% reported recent dieting, and most reported use of both health-promoting and health-compromising dieting behaviors.
Women should be informed that weight control attempts may influence their young daughters' emerging ideas, concepts, and beliefs about dieting. Mothers should be encouraged to use health-promoting rather than health-compromising weight control strategies, not only for their own well being, but to reduce the likelihood that daughters will incorporate health-compromising dieting behaviors into their concepts, ideas, and beliefs about dieting.
探讨5岁女童对节食的想法、概念和信念。
要求女童定义节食,描述节食所包含的行为,并询问节食、体重控制和体型之间的联系。家长完成关于家族健康史、人口统计学以及与食物、节食和体重控制相关问题的问卷。
研究对象/研究背景:参与者为197名5岁女童及其家长。所有女童均与亲生父母同住,且无食物过敏或慢性疾病。
对于与节食相关的5个开放式问题,将女童分为对节食有想法或没有想法两类。对这些想法、概念和信念进行分类,并采用逻辑回归分析女童节食想法的预测因素。
根据问题不同,34%至65%的5岁女童对节食有想法。与母亲不节食的女童相比,母亲报告目前或近期节食的女童对节食有想法的可能性是前者的两倍多,这表明母亲的节食行为是幼童节食想法、概念和信念的一个来源。在母亲中,超过90%报告近期节食,且大多数报告同时采用了促进健康和损害健康的节食行为。
应告知女性,控制体重的尝试可能会影响其年幼女儿对节食的新想法、概念和信念。应鼓励母亲采用促进健康而非损害健康的体重控制策略,这不仅是为了自身健康,也是为了降低女儿将损害健康的节食行为纳入其节食概念、想法和信念的可能性。