Martin R R, Lindsay D, Despas P, Bruce D, Leroux M, Anthonisen N R, Macklem P T
Am Rev Respir Dis. 1975 Feb;111(2):119-25. doi: 10.1164/arrd.1975.111.2.119.
To assess the sensitivity of tests for early, small airway obstruction, we selected 52 cigarette smokers with a ratio of 1-sec forced expiratory volume to forced vital capacity greater than 70 per cent from a smoking cessation clinic. From these subjects, 29 of the 46 tested demonstrated frequency dependence of dynamic compliance, a finding arbitrarily defined as indicative of small airway obstruction in this group. Dynamic compliance was correlated with the British Medical Research Council questionnaire, routine pulmonary function tests, closing volume as a per cent of vital capacity, maximal expiratory flow-volume curves, and flow dependence of distribution of inhaled boluses of xenon-133 (finite difference Xe). Symptoms of respiratory disease, and abnormal flow-volume curves, specific conductances, and ratios of residual volume to total lung capacity were also present in some subjects, but they correlated very poorly with frequency dependence of dynamic compliance. On the other hand, finite difference Xe was abnormal in 85 per cent of cases with frequency dependence of compliance and closing volume was abnormal in 70 per cent. In 8 of 12 subjects restudied 2 months after they stopped smoking, dynamic compliance was less frequency dependent than before smoking cessation. Similar improvements were noted in finite difference Xe, but closing volume was unchanged. Although closing volume and dynamic compliance tended to be abnormal in the same subject, concordance was not excellent, and the effects of smoking cessation suggested that the 2 tests had different determinants.
为评估早期小气道阻塞检测方法的敏感性,我们从一家戒烟诊所选取了52名吸烟者,其1秒用力呼气容积与用力肺活量之比大于70%。在这些受试者中,46名接受检测者中有29名表现出动态顺应性的频率依赖性,这一发现被随意定义为该组中小气道阻塞的指标。动态顺应性与英国医学研究委员会问卷、常规肺功能测试、闭合气量占肺活量的百分比、最大呼气流量-容积曲线以及氙-133吸入团块分布的流量依赖性(有限差分Xe)相关。一些受试者还存在呼吸系统疾病症状、异常的流量-容积曲线、比电导以及残气量与肺总量之比,但它们与动态顺应性的频率依赖性相关性很差。另一方面,在顺应性频率依赖性的病例中,85%的有限差分Xe异常,70%的闭合气量异常。在12名戒烟2个月后重新接受检测的受试者中,有8名的动态顺应性频率依赖性低于戒烟前。有限差分Xe也有类似改善,但闭合气量未变。尽管同一受试者的闭合气量和动态顺应性往往都异常,但一致性并不理想,戒烟的影响表明这两项检测有不同的决定因素。