Warren K W, Choe D S, Plaza J, Relihan M
Ann Surg. 1975 May;181(5):534-40. doi: 10.1097/00000658-197505000-00005.
This report concerns 348 pancreatoduodenectomies, including 13 total pancreatectomies. Operative mortality over 30 years was 15%, operative mortality since 1962, 10%. Precise factors influencing operability, mortality, morbidity, and long-term palliation or cure are emphasized. The necessity for making a distinction among tumors arising in the ampulla of Vater, the intrapancreatic portion of the common bile duct, and the duodenum surrounding the papilla of Vater and carcinomas arising in the head of the pancreas is the most important factor in the approach to periampullary malignant tumors. Even with this large experience, the impression of the operating surgeon at the time of resection was incorrect in 10% of the patients in whom a reons who do not resect carcinomas arising in the head of the pancreas and who may have had less experience in this specialized field may be rejecting an even larger per cent of patients with more favorable periampullary malignant tumors. The influence of previous exploration, manipulation, and biopsy on morbidity, mortality, and survival is discussed. The significance of nodal involvement and residual tumor at the neck of the pancreas and the point of division of the common bile duct and the uncinate process is discussed. These data justify continued selective application of pancreatoduodenectomy for periampullary cancer and identify areas where further improvement can be made.
本报告涉及348例胰十二指肠切除术,其中包括13例全胰切除术。30年的手术死亡率为15%,自1962年以来的手术死亡率为10%。强调了影响可手术性、死亡率、发病率以及长期缓解或治愈的精确因素。对于起源于 Vater壶腹、胆总管胰腺内段、Vater乳头周围十二指肠的肿瘤与起源于胰头的癌进行区分的必要性,是处理壶腹周围恶性肿瘤时最重要的因素。即便有如此丰富的经验,在10%的患者中,手术切除时主刀医生的判断仍是错误的,那些不切除胰头癌且在该专业领域经验较少的医生,可能会拒绝更大比例的预后较好的壶腹周围恶性肿瘤患者。讨论了既往探查、操作和活检对发病率、死亡率及生存率的影响。探讨了胰腺颈部、胆总管及钩突断端处淋巴结受累及残留肿瘤的意义。这些数据证明继续选择性地对壶腹周围癌施行胰十二指肠切除术是合理的,并确定了可进一步改进的领域。