Rucklidge J J, Tannock R
Hospital for Sick Children, Brain and Behaviour Reseacrh, Toronto, Canada.
J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2001 May;40(5):530-40. doi: 10.1097/00004583-200105000-00012.
To characterize the psychiatric, psychosocial, and cognitive functioning of female adolescents with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in comparison with female controls and males with ADHD. Female controls were also compared with male controls to verify gender differences in a nonclinical sample.
One hundred seven adolescents from Southern Ontario aged 13 to 16 were included: 24 females with ADHD, 35 males with ADHD, 28 control females, and 20 control males. All were assessed with semistructured interviews, questionnaires, and tests of achievement and intellectual functioning.
After controlling for parental education and estimated Full Scale IQ, females with ADHD were more impaired than control females in depression, anxiety, distress, teacher relationships, stress, attributional styles, and locus of control and on all cognitive and achievement measures. Females with ADHD were more impaired than males with ADHD in self-reported anxiety, distress, depression, locus of control, and vocabulary scores. These group differences were confirmed by higher ratings by parents and teachers in symptoms of psychopathology. Males with ADHD were more impaired in processing speed. Some gender differences (locus of control and vocabulary scores) were eliminated when controlling for ADHD severity. The absence of any differences between male and female controls indicates gender differences were specific to the clinical groups.
Females with ADHD are at high risk for more psychological impairment than both males with ADHD and control females. The identified psychosocial problems point to areas for intervention.
与女性对照组及患注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)的男性相比,对患ADHD的女性青少年的精神、心理社会及认知功能进行特征描述。还将女性对照组与男性对照组进行比较,以验证非临床样本中的性别差异。
纳入安大略省南部107名年龄在13至16岁的青少年:24名患ADHD的女性、35名患ADHD的男性、28名对照女性和20名对照男性。所有人均通过半结构化访谈、问卷以及成绩和智力功能测试进行评估。
在控制了父母教育程度和估计的全量表智商后,患ADHD的女性在抑郁、焦虑、痛苦、师生关系、压力、归因方式、控制点以及所有认知和成绩测量方面比对照女性受损更严重。患ADHD的女性在自我报告的焦虑、痛苦、抑郁、控制点和词汇分数方面比患ADHD的男性受损更严重。父母和教师对精神病理学症状的更高评分证实了这些组间差异。患ADHD的男性在处理速度方面受损更严重。在控制ADHD严重程度后,一些性别差异(控制点和词汇分数)消失了。男性和女性对照组之间没有任何差异,这表明性别差异特定于临床组。
患ADHD的女性比患ADHD的男性和对照女性面临更高的心理损害风险。已确定的心理社会问题指出了干预领域。