Gross-Tsur Varda, Goldzweig Gil, Landau Yael E, Berger Itai, Shmueli Dorit, Shalev Ruth S
Neuropaediatric Unit, Shaare Zedek Medical Centre, Jerusalem, Israel.
Dev Med Child Neurol. 2006 Nov;48(11):901-5. doi: 10.1017/S0012162206001976.
We compared the effect of sex and attention-deficit-hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) subtyping in groups of females and males. One hundred and one females with ADHD (mean age 10y 4mo [SD 2y 8mo]; range 5y-18y) were classified according to subtype by Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th edn) criteria (inattentive [ADHD-I]; combined [ADHD-C]) and balanced by subtype to 101 males (mean age 10y 5mo [SD 2y 9mo]; range 5y 4mo-17y 6mo). All children underwent IQ and reading assessment, and 109 underwent the continuous performance task (Test Of Variables of Attention [TOVA]). Parents completed the Conners' Abbreviated Rating Scale (ABRS), the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL), learning disability questionnaires, and reported use and efficacy of methylphenidate. Teachers completed the Swanson, Kotkin, Agler, M-Flynn, and Pelham (SKAMP) rating scale. Sex differences were found only on the CBCL; females were more impaired on the attention (p<0.001) and somatization (p=0.028) subscales but not for IQ, other questionnaires, TOVA scores, methylphenidate treatment, or demographics. Females with ADHD-C, but not males, had significantly higher T-scores than females with ADHD-I on social, attention, delinquent, and aggressive behaviours. Regardless of sex, children with ADHD-C had higher scores on all CBCL subscales (p=0.047), ABRS (p<0.001), and SKAMP (p=0.03) than children with ADHD-I. The results support the supposition that ADHD in females is the same disorder as in males. ADHD subtyping was the important determinant of ADHD core symptoms; females with ADHD were found to have significant risk of psychopathology.
我们比较了性别及注意缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)亚型在男性和女性群体中的影响。101名患有ADHD的女性(平均年龄10岁4个月[标准差2岁8个月];范围5岁至18岁)根据《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》(第4版)标准按亚型分类(注意力不集中型[ADHD-I];混合型[ADHD-C]),并按亚型与101名男性平衡(平均年龄10岁5个月[标准差2岁9个月];范围5岁4个月至17岁6个月)。所有儿童均接受了智商和阅读评估,109名儿童接受了持续性操作任务(注意力变量测试[TOVA])。家长完成了康纳斯简明评定量表(ABRS)、儿童行为检查表(CBCL)、学习障碍问卷,并报告了哌甲酯的使用情况及疗效。教师完成了斯旺森、科特金、阿格勒、M-弗林和佩勒姆(SKAMP)评定量表。仅在CBCL上发现了性别差异;女性在注意力(p<0.001)和躯体化(p=0.028)分量表上受损更严重,但在智商、其他问卷、TOVA分数、哌甲酯治疗或人口统计学方面没有差异。患有ADHD-C的女性在社交、注意力、违纪和攻击行为方面的T分数显著高于患有ADHD-I的女性,而男性则不然。无论性别如何,患有ADHD-C的儿童在所有CBCL分量表(p=0.047)、ABRS(p<0.001)和SKAMP(p=0.03)上的得分均高于患有ADHD-I的儿童。结果支持了女性ADHD与男性ADHD是同一种疾病的假设。ADHD亚型是ADHD核心症状的重要决定因素;发现患有ADHD的女性有显著的精神病理学风险。