Zwiren L D, Bar-Or O
Med Sci Sports. 1975 Summer;7(2):94-8.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the cardiopulmonary function and body composition of sedentary and highly active paraplegics. Four age-matched groups of men (n = 41) were studied: wheelchair-bound sedentary (WS), wheelchair-bound athletes of international caliber (WA), able-bodied sedentary (NS), and able-bodied athletes of national Israeli teams (NA). Although of similar height, WS were significantly (p less than .05) heavier and more obese (skinfolds) than WA and NS. Maximal oxygen consumption (VO2max arm), as measured during arm ergometry by direct open circuit spirometry, was significantly lower in WS (19.58 plus or minus 5.53 ml/kg per min) than in WA (35.00 plus or minus 7.55). The latter had significantly higher VO2max arm than did NS (25.79 plus or minus 3.98). However, no significant difference was observed between WA and NA (38.05 plus or minus 6.25). A similar trend, favoring WA over WS, was shown for maximal minute ventilation and maximal oxygen pulse. Functional lung volumes (FVC, FEV1.0, MBC) did not differ significantly between WA and WS. Heart rates at submaximal work loads were higher in WA than in NA, but markedly lower than in WS. Clear-cut conclusions can be obtained only by a longitudinal study, but these data suggest a marked decrement in cardiopulmonary functions, related to the oxygen transport system, in men whose lower limbs have been immobilized for years. A reversed trend is shown for paraplegics who regularly activate their upper limbs and trunk muscles.
本研究的目的是评估久坐不动和高度活跃的截瘫患者的心肺功能和身体成分。对四组年龄匹配的男性(n = 41)进行了研究:轮椅束缚的久坐者(WS)、国际水平的轮椅运动员(WA)、健全的久坐者(NS)以及以色列国家队的健全运动员(NA)。尽管身高相似,但WS比WA和NS明显更重且更肥胖(皮褶厚度)(p小于0.05)。通过直接开路肺量计在手臂测力计测试期间测量的最大耗氧量(VO2max手臂),WS(19.58±5.53毫升/千克每分钟)显著低于WA(35.00±7.55)。后者的VO2max手臂显著高于NS(25.79±3.98)。然而,WA和NA之间未观察到显著差异(38.05±6.25)。最大分钟通气量和最大氧脉搏也显示出类似的趋势,即WA优于WS。WA和WS之间的功能性肺容量(FVC、FEV1.0、MBC)没有显著差异。次最大工作负荷下的心率,WA高于NA,但明显低于WS。只有通过纵向研究才能得出明确的结论,但这些数据表明,对于下肢多年固定不动的男性,与氧运输系统相关的心肺功能显著下降。对于经常活动上肢和躯干肌肉的截瘫患者则呈现相反的趋势。