Tremblay M, Gervais A, Lacroix C, O'Loughlin J, Makni H, Paradis G
Direction de la santé publique, Régie régionale de la santé et des services sociaux de Montréal-Centre, Division of Preventive Medicine, McGill University Health Center, Montreal, Que.
CMAJ. 2001 Sep 4;165(5):601-7.
In 1997 the Direction de la santé publique de Montréal-Centre initiated "Physicians Taking Action Against Smoking," a 5-year intervention program to improve the smoking cessation counselling practices of general practitioners (GPs) in Montreal. Program development was guided by the precede-proceed model. This model advocates identifying factors influencing the outcome, in this case counselling practices. These factors are then used to determine the program objectives, to develop and tailor program activities and to design the evaluation. Program activities during the first 3 years included cessation counselling workshops and conferences for GPs, publication of articles in professional interest journals, publication of clinical guidelines for smoking cessation counselling and dissemination of educational material for both GPs and smokers. The program also supported activities encouraging smokers to ask their GPs to help them stop smoking. Results from 2 cross-sectional surveys, conducted in 1998 and 2000, of random samples of approximately 300 GPs suggest some improvements over time in several counselling practices, including offering counselling to more patients and discussing setting a quit date. More improvements were observed among female than male GPs in both psychosocial factors related to counselling and specific counselling practices. For example, improvements were noted among female GPs in self-perceived ability to provide effective counselling and in the belief that it is important to schedule specific appointments to help patients quit; in addition, the perceived importance of several barriers to counselling decreased among female GPs. A greater proportion of the female respondents to the 2000 survey offered written educational material than was the case in 1998, and a greater proportion of the male GPs devoted more time to counselling in 2000 than in 1998; however, among male GPs the proportion who discussed the pros and cons of smoking with patients in the pre-contemplation stage declined between 1998 and 2000, as did the proportion who referred patients in the preparation stage to community resources. Our experience suggests that an integrated, theory-based program to improve physicians' counselling practices could be a key component of a comprehensive strategy to reduce tobacco use.
1997年,蒙特利尔市中心公共卫生管理部门发起了“医生戒烟行动”,这是一项为期5年的干预项目,旨在改善蒙特利尔市全科医生(GP)的戒烟咨询服务。项目开发以“倾向 - 行动”模型为指导。该模型主张识别影响结果的因素,在此案例中即咨询服务。然后利用这些因素确定项目目标、制定并调整项目活动以及设计评估方案。前3年的项目活动包括为全科医生举办戒烟咨询研讨会和会议、在专业兴趣期刊上发表文章、发布戒烟咨询临床指南以及为全科医生和吸烟者分发教育材料。该项目还支持鼓励吸烟者请全科医生帮助他们戒烟的活动。1998年和2000年对约300名全科医生随机样本进行的两次横断面调查结果表明,随着时间推移,在一些咨询服务方面有了改进,包括为更多患者提供咨询以及讨论设定戒烟日期。在与咨询相关的心理社会因素和特定咨询服务方面,女性全科医生比男性全科医生有更多改进。例如,女性全科医生在自我感知的提供有效咨询的能力以及认为安排特定预约以帮助患者戒烟很重要的信念方面有所改善;此外,女性全科医生认为的一些咨询障碍的重要性降低。2000年调查中,提供书面教育材料的女性受访者比例高于1998年,2000年投入更多时间进行咨询的男性全科医生比例高于1998年;然而,在男性全科医生中,1998年至2000年期间,在戒烟前阶段与患者讨论吸烟利弊的比例以及将处于准备阶段的患者转介至社区资源的比例均有所下降。我们的经验表明,一个基于理论的综合项目,以改善医生的咨询服务,可能是减少烟草使用综合策略的关键组成部分。