Brugha Ruairí, Starling Mary, Walt Gill
Health Policy Unit, Department of Public Health and Policy, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London WC1E 7HT, UK.
Lancet. 2002 Feb 2;359(9304):435-8. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(02)07607-9.
The Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunization (GAVI) is seen as a model for the new Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria, to be launched early in 2002. We did an assessment in four African countries to report the experiences of ministries of health and their partners in applying to GAVI for funds to strengthen health systems and for new vaccines. Countries welcomed the introduction of hepatitis B vaccine, safe injection equipment, and the financial support to strengthen immunisation programmes. All reported that the pace of the application process was too rapid. District visits revealed low staffing levels, insufficient transport and fuel, poorly functioning cold chains, and infrequent supervision. Information systems were unreliable, which will be an obstacle to GAVI when monitoring and rewarding improvements in immunisation coverage. Also, the high cost of expensive new vaccines will be difficult to sustain if GAVI funding stops at the end of its 5 year commitment. Our study suggests that applications for support and planning for AIDS, tuberculosis, and malaria control under the new Global Fund, will be more complex and demanding on already over-stretched ministries of health. Further, the rapid onset of activities, coupled with uncertainty about the time-scale of donor commitment, could be problematic. A limited and carefully assessed set of initial activities, focusing on where and how to strengthen existing country systems, is more likely to be successful and could provide useful models for scaling-up to larger programmes in different contexts.
全球疫苗和免疫联盟(GAVI)被视为将于2002年初启动的抗击艾滋病、结核病和疟疾全球基金的典范。我们在四个非洲国家进行了评估,以报告各国卫生部及其合作伙伴向GAVI申请资金以加强卫生系统和采购新疫苗的经历。各国对引入乙肝疫苗、安全注射设备以及用于加强免疫规划的财政支持表示欢迎。所有国家都报告称,申请流程的速度太快。实地考察发现人员配备不足、交通和燃料短缺、冷链运作不佳以及监督不频繁。信息系统不可靠,这将成为GAVI监测和奖励免疫覆盖率提高情况的障碍。此外,如果GAVI在其5年承诺期结束时停止提供资金,昂贵新疫苗的高昂成本将难以维持。我们的研究表明,根据新的全球基金申请艾滋病、结核病和疟疾控制的支持及规划,将更加复杂,对本已不堪重负的各国卫生部要求也更高。此外,活动迅速开展,再加上捐助方承诺的时间范围不确定,可能会出现问题。一套有限且经过仔细评估的初始活动,重点关注加强现有国家系统的地点和方式,更有可能取得成功,并可为在不同情况下扩大到更大规模的项目提供有用的模式。