Gray Gregory C, Reed Robert J, Kaiser Kevin S, Smith Tyler C, Gastañaga Victor M
Department of Defense Center for Deployment Health Research, Naval Health Research Center, San Diego, CA, USA.
Am J Epidemiol. 2002 Jun 1;155(11):1033-44. doi: 10.1093/aje/155.11.1033.
US Navy Seabees have been among the most symptomatic Gulf War veterans. Beginning in May 1997, the authors mailed Gulf War-era Seabees a health survey in serial mailings. As of July 1, 1999, 68.6% of 17,559 Seabees contacted had returned the questionnaire. Compared with other Seabees, Gulf War Seabees reported poorer general health, a higher prevalence of all 33 medical problems assessed, more cognition difficulties, and a higher prevalence of four physician-diagnosed multisymptom conditions: chronic fatigue syndrome, posttraumatic stress disorder, multiple chemical sensitivity, and irritable bowel syndrome. Because the four multisymptom conditions were highly associated with one another, the authors aggregated them into a working case definition of Gulf War illness. Among the 3,831 (22% cases) Gulf War Seabee participants, multivariable modeling revealed that female, Reserve, and enlisted personnel and participants belonging to either of two particular Seabee units were most likely to meet the case definition. Twelve of 34 self-reported Gulf War exposures were mildly associated with meeting the definition of Gulf War illness, with exposure to fumes from munitions having the highest odds ratio (odds ratio = 1.9, 95% confidence interval: 1.5, 2.4). While these data do not implicate a specific etiologic exposure, they demonstrate a strong association and a high prevalence of self-reported multisymptom conditions in a large group of symptomatic Gulf War veterans.
美国海军工程营成员一直是海湾战争退伍军人中症状最为明显的群体之一。从1997年5月开始,作者们陆续向海湾战争时期的海军工程营成员邮寄健康调查问卷。截至1999年7月1日,在17559名被联系的海军工程营成员中,68.6%的人返回了问卷。与其他海军工程营成员相比,海湾战争时期的海军工程营成员报告称总体健康状况较差,在评估的所有33种医疗问题中患病率更高,认知困难更多,并且在四种医生诊断的多症状疾病中患病率更高:慢性疲劳综合征、创伤后应激障碍、多重化学物质过敏和肠易激综合征。由于这四种多症状疾病彼此高度相关,作者们将它们汇总成海湾战争疾病的一个工作病例定义。在3831名(占22%)海湾战争时期的海军工程营参与者中,多变量建模显示,女性、预备役人员、入伍人员以及属于两个特定海军工程营单位之一的参与者最有可能符合病例定义。在34种自我报告的海湾战争暴露情况中,有12种与符合海湾战争疾病定义存在轻度关联,其中接触弹药烟雾的比值比最高(比值比 = 1.9,95%置信区间:1.5,2.4)。虽然这些数据并未表明存在特定的病因暴露,但它们显示出在一大群有症状的海湾战争退伍军人中,自我报告的多症状疾病之间存在强烈关联且患病率很高。