Colquhoun D, Hatton C J, Hawkes A G
Department of Pharmacology, University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK.
J Physiol. 2003 Mar 15;547(Pt 3):699-728. doi: 10.1113/jphysiol.2002.034165. Epub 2003 Jan 24.
Properties of maximum likelihood estimators of rate constants for channel mechanisms are investigated, to see what can and cannot be inferred from experimental results. The implementation of the HJCFIT method is described; it maximises the likelihood of an entire sequence of apparent open and shut times, with the rate constants in a specified reaction mechanism as free parameters. The exact method for missed brief events is used. Several methods for testing the quality of the fit are described. The distributions of rate constants, and correlations between them, are investigated by doing sets of 1000 fits to simulated experiments. In a standard nicotinic receptor mechanism, all nine free rate constants can be estimated even from one single channel recording, as long as the two binding sites are independent, even when the number of channels in the patch is not known. The estimates of rate constants that apply to diliganded channels are robust; good estimates can be obtained even with erroneous assumptions (e.g. about the value of a fixed rate constant or the independence of sites). Rate constants that require distinction between the two sites are less robust, and require that an EC50 be specified, or that records at two concentrations be fitted simultaneously. Despite the complexity of the problem, it appears that there exist two solutions with very similar likelihoods, as in the simplest case. The hazards that result from this, and from the strong positive correlation between estimates of opening and shutting rates, are discussed.
研究了通道机制速率常数最大似然估计量的性质,以了解从实验结果中可以推断出什么以及不能推断出什么。描述了HJCFIT方法的实现;它以指定反应机制中的速率常数作为自由参数,最大化了整个明显开放和关闭时间序列的似然性。使用了处理遗漏短暂事件的精确方法。描述了几种检验拟合质量的方法。通过对模拟实验进行1000组拟合,研究了速率常数的分布及其之间的相关性。在标准的烟碱样受体机制中,即使斑块中的通道数量未知,只要两个结合位点是独立的,所有九个自由速率常数甚至可以从单个通道记录中估计出来。适用于双配体通道的速率常数估计是稳健的;即使有错误的假设(例如关于固定速率常数的值或位点的独立性),也可以获得良好的估计。区分两个位点所需的速率常数不太稳健,需要指定EC50,或者同时拟合两种浓度下的记录。尽管问题很复杂,但似乎与最简单的情况一样,存在两个似然性非常相似的解。讨论了由此产生的风险以及开放和关闭速率估计之间的强正相关性。