Pshetizky Yaacov, Naimer Sody, Shvartzman Pesach
Family Medicine Department, Sial Research Center for Family Medicine and Primary Care, Division of Community Health, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Clalit Health Services, 84105 Beer-Sheva, Israel.
Fam Pract. 2003 Aug;20(4):417-9. doi: 10.1093/fampra/cmg414.
Acute otitis media (AOM) is a common self-limiting disease in children. Antibiotic use is controversial. Physicians in the USA and in Israel prescribe antibiotics almost universally, while physicians in other countries report good outcome without any treatment. Parents' expectation is an important factor influencing a physician's decision to prescribe antibiotics.
Our aim was to assess whether a brief explanation to parents regarding the self-limited nature of AOM and the controversy regarding antibiotic prescription for the disease will influence the parents' decision regarding antibiotics use.
Parents of the children participating in the study in two primary care clinics belonging to HMO-Clalit Health Services (CHS) in the southern district of Israel were randomly assigned to an intervention (44) and control (37) group. The intervention group received the brief explanation. The two groups received prescription for antibiotics. The subjects comprised 81 children aged 3 months to 4 years visiting the family practice clinics and diagnosed with AOM. The rate of antibiotics purchase, using the prescription given and the factors influencing the decision were evaluated.
Fewer parents administered antibiotics to their children in the intervention group compared with the control group (37% versus 63%, respectively, P < 0.0001). Mother's education level was the only factor found to be significantly lower in the group that eventually purchased antibiotics (P < 0.05).
In children with AOM, a brief explanation by the family physician to the child's parents about the disease and the expected spontaneous recovery could decrease antibiotic use by approximately 50%.
急性中耳炎(AOM)是儿童常见的自限性疾病。抗生素的使用存在争议。美国和以色列的医生几乎普遍开具抗生素,而其他国家的医生报告称未经任何治疗也有良好的治疗效果。家长的期望是影响医生开具抗生素决定的一个重要因素。
我们的目的是评估向家长简要解释AOM的自限性本质以及该病抗生素处方的争议是否会影响家长关于抗生素使用的决定。
在以色列南部地区属于克拉利特健康服务组织(CHS)的两家初级保健诊所参与研究的儿童家长被随机分为干预组(44名)和对照组(37名)。干预组接受了简要解释。两组均收到了抗生素处方。研究对象包括81名年龄在3个月至4岁之间、前往家庭医疗诊所就诊并被诊断为AOM的儿童。评估了使用所开处方购买抗生素的比例以及影响该决定的因素。
与对照组相比,干预组中给孩子使用抗生素的家长更少(分别为37%和63%,P<0.0001)。最终购买抗生素的组中,母亲的教育水平是唯一被发现显著较低的因素(P<0.05)。
对于患有AOM的儿童,家庭医生向孩子家长简要解释该病及预期的自然康复情况可使抗生素使用减少约50%。