Fell James C, Ferguson Susan A, Williams Allan F, Fields Michele
Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation, 11710 Beltsville Drive, Suite 300, Calverton, MD 20705-3102, USA.
Accid Anal Prev. 2003 Nov;35(6):897-902. doi: 10.1016/s0001-4575(02)00097-0.
Sobriety checkpoints have been used by police in the United States for at least the past two decades to enforce impaired driving laws. Research has indicated that sobriety checkpoints are effective in reducing drinking and driving and alcohol-related fatal crashes. Despite this evidence, many police agencies have been unenthusiastic about using checkpoints. Information was collected from all 50 states plus the District of Columbia on the use of sobriety checkpoints. A total of 37 states and the District of Columbia reported conducting sobriety checkpoints at least once or twice during the year. Only 11 states reported that checkpoints were conducted on a weekly basis. Thirteen states do not conduct checkpoints either because of legal or policy issues. More detailed information was collected from five states that conduct checkpoints frequently and matched with information from five similar states that conduct checkpoints infrequently. States with frequent checkpoint programs had several common features such as program themes, support from task forces and citizen activist groups, use of a moderate number of police at the checkpoints, and use of all available funding mechanisms (federal, state, local) to support them. States with infrequent checkpoints claimed a lack of funding and police resources for not conducting more checkpoints, preferred saturation patrols over checkpoints because they were more "productive," and used large numbers of police officers at checkpoints. Ways to overcome perceived barriers to checkpoint use are discussed.
在美国,至少在过去二十年里,警方一直在使用清醒度检查站来执行酒驾法律。研究表明,清醒度检查站在减少酒后驾车和与酒精相关的致命撞车事故方面是有效的。尽管有这些证据,但许多警察机构对使用检查站并不热心。我们从美国50个州以及哥伦比亚特区收集了关于清醒度检查站使用情况的信息。共有37个州和哥伦比亚特区报告称在一年中至少进行了一两次清醒度检查。只有11个州报告称每周都进行检查站检查。有13个州由于法律或政策问题不进行检查站检查。我们从五个经常进行检查站检查的州收集了更详细的信息,并与五个类似的但很少进行检查站检查的州的信息进行了匹配。经常开展检查站项目的州有几个共同特点,比如项目主题、得到特别行动小组和公民维权组织的支持、在检查站配备适度数量的警察,以及利用所有可用的资金机制(联邦、州、地方)来支持这些项目。很少进行检查站检查的州称,由于缺乏资金和警力资源而无法开展更多检查站检查,他们更喜欢饱和式巡逻而不是检查站检查,因为他们觉得饱和式巡逻更“有成效”,而且在检查站使用大量警察。本文还讨论了克服在使用检查站方面所察觉到的障碍的方法。