Risberg Gunilla, Hamberg Katarina, Johansson Eva E
Department of Public Health and Clinical Medicine, Family Medicine, Umeå University, Sweden.
BMC Med Educ. 2003 Oct 27;3:8. doi: 10.1186/1472-6920-3-8.
An important goal for medical education today is professional development including gender equality and awareness of gender issues. Are medical teachers prepared for this task? We investigated gender awareness among physician teachers, expressed as their attitudes towards the role of gender in professional relationships, and how it varied with physician gender and specialty. We discuss how this might be related to the gender climate and sex segregation in different specialties.
Questionnaires were sent to all 468 specialists in the clinical departments and in family medicine, who were engaged in educating medical students at a Swedish university. They were asked to rate, on visual analogue scales, the importance of physician and patient gender in consultation, of preceptor and student gender in clinical tutoring and of physician gender in other professional encounters. Differences between family physicians, surgical, and non-surgical hospital doctors, and between women and men were estimated by chi-2 tests and multivariate logistic regression analyses.
The response rate was 65 %. There were differences between specialty groups in all investigated areas mainly due to disparities among men. The odds for a male family physician to assess gender important were three times higher, and for a male non-surgical doctor two times higher when compared to a male surgical doctor. Female teachers assessed gender important to a higher degree than men. Among women there were no significant differences between specialty groups.
There was an interaction between physician teachers' gender and specialty as to whether they identified gender as important in professional relationships. Male physicians, especially from the surgical group, assessed gender important to a significantly lower degree than female physicians. Physicians' degree of gender awareness may, as one of many factors, affect working climate and the distribution of women and men in different specialties. Therefore, to improve working climate and reduce segregation we suggest efforts to increase gender awareness among physicians, for example educational programs where continuous reflections about gender attitudes are encouraged.
当今医学教育的一个重要目标是专业发展,包括性别平等和对性别问题的认识。医学教师是否为这项任务做好了准备?我们调查了医师教师中的性别意识,以他们对性别在职业关系中的作用的态度来表示,并探讨其如何随医师性别和专业而变化。我们讨论了这可能如何与不同专业中的性别氛围和性别隔离相关。
向瑞典一所大学中所有468名从事医学生教育的临床科室和家庭医学专业的专家发放问卷。要求他们在视觉模拟量表上对医师和患者性别在会诊中的重要性、带教老师和学生性别在临床辅导中的重要性以及医师性别在其他职业接触中的重要性进行评分。通过卡方检验和多因素逻辑回归分析估计家庭医生、外科医生和非外科医院医生之间以及男女之间的差异。
回复率为65%。在所有调查领域中,专业组之间存在差异,主要是由于男性之间的差异。与男性外科医生相比,男性家庭医生认为性别重要的几率高出三倍,男性非外科医生高出两倍。女教师比男教师更重视性别。在女性中,专业组之间没有显著差异。
医师教师的性别和专业在他们是否认为性别在职业关系中重要方面存在相互作用。男性医师,尤其是外科组的男性,认为性别重要的程度明显低于女性医师。医师的性别意识程度可能作为众多因素之一,影响工作氛围以及不同专业中男女的分布。因此,为了改善工作氛围并减少隔离,我们建议努力提高医师的性别意识,例如开展鼓励持续反思性别态度的教育项目。