Thomason J Mark, Lund James P, Chehade Antoine, Feine Jocelyne S
School of Dental Sciences, University of Newcastle, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom.
Int J Prosthodont. 2003 Sep-Oct;16(5):467-73.
This study examined patient satisfaction with conventional complete dentures and mandibular implant overdentures opposing conventional maxillary dentures 6 months after delivery.
Sixty edentulous subjects (aged 65 to 75 years) were randomly assigned to either a mandibular conventional denture or an overdenture supported by two implants with ball-shaped retentive anchors. Patients rated their general satisfaction and other features of their prostheses, together with their ability to eat certain food items, on 100-mm visual analogue scales before assignment, and after 2 and 6 months.
Both treatment groups reported greater satisfaction with their new prostheses at 6 months. General satisfaction ratings were higher in the implant group than in the conventional denture group by approximately 36% (mean difference 22.3 mm). The implant group also rated comfort (mean difference 22.4 mm), stability (mean difference 28.5 mm), and ability to chew (mean difference 17.3 mm) significantly higher. Significantly higher scores were also given by the implant group for their ability to chew certain hard foods. A trend for an increase in the differences between the groups, in favor of the implant group, was observed between the 2- and 6-month recalls, although the increase was only significant for ease of cleaning. The primary influence on general satisfaction 6 months after the delivery of the prostheses was the provision of the two-implant overdenture.
Edentulous seniors who received mandibular implant overdentures opposing a conventional denture rated their general satisfaction approximately 36% higher than did a comparable group provided with new conventional dentures.
本研究调查了患者在佩戴传统全口义齿和下颌种植覆盖义齿(与传统上颌义齿相对)6个月后对其的满意度。
60名无牙颌受试者(年龄65至75岁)被随机分为两组,一组佩戴下颌传统义齿,另一组佩戴由两个带有球形固位锚的种植体支持的覆盖义齿。患者在分配前、2个月和6个月后,使用100毫米视觉模拟量表对其总体满意度、义齿的其他特征以及食用某些食物的能力进行评分。
两个治疗组在6个月时均对新义齿表示出更高的满意度。种植体组的总体满意度评分比传统义齿组高约36%(平均差异22.3毫米)。种植体组在舒适度(平均差异22.4毫米)、稳定性(平均差异28.5毫米)和咀嚼能力(平均差异17.3毫米)方面的评分也显著更高。种植体组在咀嚼某些硬食物的能力方面得分也显著更高。在2个月和6个月的回访之间,观察到两组之间的差异有增加的趋势,有利于种植体组,尽管这种增加仅在清洁容易程度方面显著。义齿交付6个月后,对总体满意度的主要影响因素是使用了双种植体覆盖义齿。
佩戴与传统义齿相对的下颌种植覆盖义齿的无牙颌老年人对其总体满意度比接受新传统义齿的类似组高约36%。