Rothwell Gar W, Van Atta Michelle R, Ballard Harvey E, Stockey Ruth A
Department of Environmental and Plant Biology, Ohio University, Athens, OH 45701, USA.
Mol Phylogenet Evol. 2004 Feb;30(2):378-85. doi: 10.1016/s1055-7903(03)00205-7.
We test competing hypotheses of relationships among Aroids (Araceae) and duckweeds (Lemnaceae) using sequences of the trnL-trnF spacer region of the chloroplast genome. Included in the analysis were 22 aroid genera including Pistia and five genera of Lemnaceae including the recently segregated genus Landoltia. Aponogeton was used as an outgroup to root the tree. A data set of 522 aligned nucleotides yielded maximum parsimony and maximum likelihood trees similar to those previously derived from restriction site data. Pistia and the Lemnaceae are placed in two separate and well-supported clades, suggesting at least two independent origins of the floating aquatic growth form within the aroid clade. Within the Lemnaceae there is only partial support for the paradigm of sequential morphological reduction, given that Wolffia is sister to Wolffiella+Lemna. As in the results of the restriction site analysis, pantropical Pistia is placed with Colocasia and Typhonium of southeastern Asia, indicative of Old World affinities. Branch lengths leading to duckweed terminal taxa are much longer relative to other ingroup taxa (including Pistia), evidently as a result of higher rates of nucleotide substitutions and insertion/deletion events. Morphological reduction within the duckweeds roughly correlates with accelerated chloroplast genome evolution.
我们使用叶绿体基因组trnL-trnF间隔区序列,对天南星科(Araceae)植物与浮萍科(Lemnaceae)植物之间关系的相互竞争假说进行了检验。分析中包括22个天南星科属,其中有大薸属(Pistia),以及浮萍科的5个属,包括最近新分出的细绿萍属(Landoltia)。水蕹科(Aponogeton)被用作外类群来确定树的根。一个由522个比对核苷酸组成的数据集产生了与先前从限制性位点数据得出的那些树相似的最大简约树和最大似然树。大薸属和浮萍科被置于两个独立且得到有力支持的分支中,这表明在天南星科分支内,漂浮水生生长形式至少有两个独立起源。在浮萍科内,对于形态依次简化的范式只有部分支持,因为无根萍属(Wolffia)是无根萍亚属(Wolffiella)和浮萍属(Lemna)的姐妹群。正如在限制性位点分析结果中那样,泛热带的大薸属与东南亚的芋属(Colocasia)和犁头尖属(Typhonium)归在一起,表明其与旧世界的亲缘关系。相对于其他内类群分类单元(包括大薸属),通向浮萍终端分类单元的分支长度要长得多,这显然是核苷酸替换率和插入/缺失事件较高的结果。浮萍科内的形态简化大致与叶绿体基因组进化加速相关。