Pollard P
Department of Psychology, University of Central Lancashire, Preston, UK.
Br J Soc Psychol. 1992 Dec;31 ( Pt 4):307-26. doi: 10.1111/j.2044-8309.1992.tb00975.x.
This paper reviews the effects on subjects' judgements of a variety of factors that have been included in experimental depictions of rape. The focus is on attribution of responsibility or fault to the victim or attacker and related judgements, particularly regarding guilt and sanctions. Generally, females make more pro-victim judgements than do males, and people with non-traditional sex-role attitudes make more pro-victim judgements than do holders of more traditional views. Other factors covered are various victim characteristics, victim-attacker acquaintance, resistance, and victim attire and a range of behaviours prior to the attack. These are limits to generalization due to populations studied and methods used, and the observed effects of several factors are either minimal or inconsistent. However, some factors have reliable effects on judgements, which it is argued are explainable in terms of their link with traditional beliefs about women's rights and roles. Males have often been found to be more susceptible to these effects. In particular, it appears that if a female engages in any behaviour deemed to be 'incautious' that results in victimization then she may be perceived to be at fault, even though these behaviours would be 'legitimate' for males, and that prior romantic involvement with the attacker mitigates the perceived seriousness of, and may even be seen as supplying justification for, a sexual attack. The existence of these attitudes implies that rape may be tacitly condoned in many situations.
本文回顾了在强奸案实验描述中所包含的各种因素对受试者判断的影响。重点在于对受害者或攻击者责任或过错的归因以及相关判断,特别是关于罪责和制裁。一般来说,女性比男性做出更多支持受害者的判断,具有非传统性别角色态度的人比持有更传统观点的人做出更多支持受害者的判断。所涵盖的其他因素包括各种受害者特征、受害者与攻击者的相识情况、抵抗、受害者着装以及攻击前的一系列行为。由于所研究的人群和使用的方法,存在普遍化的局限性,并且几个因素的观察效果要么很小,要么不一致。然而,一些因素对判断有可靠的影响,有人认为这可以从它们与关于妇女权利和角色的传统观念的联系方面来解释。人们经常发现男性更容易受到这些影响。特别是,如果一名女性从事任何被认为是“不谨慎”的行为而导致受害,那么她可能会被认为有过错,即使这些行为对男性来说是“合理的”,而且与攻击者先前的浪漫关系会减轻对性攻击严重性的认知,甚至可能被视为为性攻击提供了正当理由。这些态度的存在意味着在许多情况下强奸可能会被默许。