Mahony J B, Luinstra K E, Jang D, Sellors J, Chernesky M A
McMaster University Regional Virology and Chlamydiology Laboratory, St. Joseph's Hospital, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
Mol Cell Probes. 1992 Oct;6(5):381-8. doi: 10.1016/0890-8508(92)90031-r.
A plasmid-based PCR for the detection of Chlamydia trachomatis was evaluated with a confirmatory PCR employing a second set of plasmid primers. A total of 258 genitourinary specimens including 134 female endocervical and urethral specimens and 124 male urethral specimens were tested by culture, blocked EIA and PCR. Fifty-four specimens were positive by culture, 50 were positive by EIA and 71 were positive by PCR. Fourteen specimens that were PCR-positive but culture- and EIA-negative were confirmed positive by the confirmatory PCR. Two of the 187 specimens which were negative by culture and EIA were positive by PCR but failed to confirm with the second set of primers. Using an expanded gold standard of culture, blocked EIA and confirmed PCR, the overall sensitivities for culture, blocked EIA and confirmed PCR were 76.0% (54/71), 70.4% (50/71) and 100% (71/71) and the specificities were 100% (187/187), 100% (187/187), respectively. These results demonstrated that a confirmatory PCR was useful for sorting out discordant specimens and establishing the true specificity of PCR. Furthermore, these results demonstrate that PCR is more sensitive than culture and EIA and suggest that a confirmed PCR test should be included in the gold standard for the evaluation of new tests for diagnosing Chlamydia trachomatis infections.
采用第二组质粒引物的验证性PCR对一种基于质粒的沙眼衣原体检测PCR进行了评估。共对258份泌尿生殖系统标本进行了检测,其中包括134份女性宫颈和尿道标本以及124份男性尿道标本,检测方法包括培养法、阻断酶免疫测定法(EIA)和PCR。培养法检测出54份标本呈阳性,EIA检测出50份标本呈阳性,PCR检测出71份标本呈阳性。14份PCR检测呈阳性但培养法和EIA检测呈阴性的标本经验证性PCR确认为阳性。187份培养法和EIA检测呈阴性的标本中有2份PCR检测呈阳性,但未能通过第二组引物得到确认。采用培养法、阻断EIA和经确认的PCR这种扩展的金标准,培养法、阻断EIA和经确认的PCR的总体灵敏度分别为76.0%(54/71)、70.4%(50/71)和100%(71/71),特异性分别为100%(187/187)、100%(187/187)。这些结果表明,验证性PCR有助于筛选出不一致的标本并确定PCR的真正特异性。此外,这些结果表明PCR比培养法和EIA更敏感,并建议在评估沙眼衣原体感染新检测方法的金标准中应纳入经确认的PCR检测。