Kirkevold Oyvind, Sandvik Leiv, Engedal Knut
Norwegian Centre for Dementia Research, Vestfold Mental Health Care Trust, Tønsberg N-3107, Norway.
Int J Geriatr Psychiatry. 2004 Oct;19(10):980-8. doi: 10.1002/gps.1197.
To analyse the effect of patient and ward characteristics on the use of constraints in nursing homes.
Primary carers in 222 wards in Norwegian nursing homes were asked about use of constraints towards 1926 patients during seven days. Constraints were grouped as mechanical restraints, non-mechanical restraints, electronic surveillance, force or pressure in medical examination or treatment, and force or pressure in ADL. The patients' mental capacity (CDR score), activity in daily living (ADL) and behaviour (BARS score) were rated. Type and size of ward, staffing level and educational level of the staff was recorded.
In all 758 of the patients were subjected to any constraint. Degree of dementia, aggressive behaviour and loss of function in ADL had significant impact on all types of constraint except for electronical surveillance. The strongest associations were found between degree of dementia and mechanical restraint (OR 5.14), impaired ADL and mechanical restraint (OR 9.23) and aggression and force or pressure in ADL (OR 3.75). Mechanical restraint was less used towards patients in special care units for persons with dementia (SCU) (OR 0.38) compared to patients in regular units (RU), whereas non-mechanical restraint was more frequent used in SCUs (OR 2.28). Type of ward had no significant impact on use of other types of constraints. Staff level and education level of the staff had no significant impact on the use of constraint.
Constraint is frequently used in nursing homes, and most frequent toward patients with severe dementia, aggressive behaviour or low ADL function.
分析患者及病房特征对养老院约束措施使用情况的影响。
对挪威养老院222个病房的主要护理人员进行询问,了解其在七天内对1926名患者采取约束措施的情况。约束措施分为机械约束、非机械约束、电子监控、医疗检查或治疗中的强制或压力以及日常生活活动(ADL)中的强制或压力。对患者的认知能力(CDR评分)、日常生活活动能力(ADL)及行为(BARS评分)进行评估。记录病房的类型和规模、工作人员配备水平及教育程度。
共有758名患者受到了某种约束。痴呆程度、攻击行为及ADL功能丧失对除电子监控外的所有类型约束均有显著影响。痴呆程度与机械约束之间(比值比[OR]5.14)、ADL受损与机械约束之间(OR 9.23)以及攻击行为与ADL中的强制或压力之间(OR 3.75)的关联最为强烈。与普通病房(RU)的患者相比,痴呆症患者特殊护理单元(SCU)的患者接受机械约束的情况较少(OR 0.38),而SCU中使用非机械约束更为频繁(OR 2.28)。病房类型对其他类型约束措施的使用没有显著影响。工作人员水平和教育程度对约束措施的使用没有显著影响。
养老院中经常使用约束措施,且在患有严重痴呆、攻击行为或ADL功能低下的患者中使用最为频繁。