Khan K S, Dwarakanath L S, Pakkal M, Brace V, Awonuga A
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Birmingham Women's Hospital, UK.
J Obstet Gynaecol. 1999 May;19(3):231-4. doi: 10.1080/01443619964968.
We assessed the feasibility of a new educational programme to teach critical appraisal of the medical literature to postgraduate trainees. The new programme used a journal club format where selection of topics and articles was driven by clinical problems arising in day-to-day practice. Papers were appraised critically according to validated guidelines using computer software for appraisal, electronic storage and retrieval. Over the initial 4-month period the journal club produced 17 critically appraised topics, two of which were published in peer-reviewed journals. During the study, trainees' reading time improved from a median of 2.0 hours (range 1-5 hours) to 3.5 hours (range 2-8 hours) (P = 0.026) and their knowledge scores improved from a mean of 50.8 (SD 4.0) to 62.9 (SD 4.3) (P = 0.003). We conclude that a journal club supported by electronic means of critical appraisal and dissemination of appraised information can be used to encourage the practice of evidence-based medicine.
我们评估了一项新教育计划的可行性,该计划旨在向研究生培训学员传授医学文献的批判性评价方法。新计划采用期刊俱乐部的形式,其中主题和文章的选择由日常实践中出现的临床问题驱动。根据经过验证的指南,使用计算机软件进行评估、电子存储和检索,对论文进行批判性评价。在最初的4个月期间,期刊俱乐部产生了17个经过批判性评价的主题,其中两个发表在同行评审期刊上。在研究过程中,学员的阅读时间从中位数2.0小时(范围1 - 5小时)提高到3.5小时(范围2 - 8小时)(P = 0.026),他们的知识得分从平均50.8(标准差4.0)提高到62.9(标准差4.3)(P = 0.003)。我们得出结论,通过电子手段进行批判性评价和传播评价信息支持的期刊俱乐部可用于鼓励循证医学的实践。