Ottman Ruth, Berenson Karina, Barker-Cummings Christie
G.H. Sergievsky Center and Department of Epidemiology, Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University, New York, New York 10032, USA.
Epilepsia. 2005 Feb;46(2):290-7. doi: 10.1111/j.0013-9580.2005.41904.x.
Study of families containing multiple affected individuals is essential for genetic research on the epilepsies, yet practically nothing has been published about methods for identification and recruitment of families or expected participation rates. Here we describe the strategy used for data collection in a genetic linkage study, to provide guidelines for efficient design of new studies.
Potentially eligible families were ascertained from private physicians, clinics, and self-referrals. Participation rates were examined at each step of the recruitment process, according to ascertainment source, initial contact method, gender, and ethnicity.
Among 320 potentially eligible families identified, only 68 (21%) were successfully enrolled. Contact was established with an index subject in 83% of families, and a screen for eligibility was completed in 88% of these. However, only 54% of screened families were confirmed to be eligible, and of these, only 54% were enrolled. In eligible families, 79% of index subjects agreed to participate; the low family enrollment rates resulted largely from refusals by other family members whose participation was needed for linkage analysis. At each step in the recruitment process, the participation rate was higher in self-referred than in other families.
Recruitment of families for genetic studies is labor-intensive; many potentially eligible families may have to be screened for each family enrolled. Recruitment is easier with self-referred families than with those identified through other methods. The introduction of standardized methods for identification of eligible families from clinical settings can improve efficiency.
对于癫痫的遗传学研究而言,对包含多个患病个体的家系进行研究至关重要,但实际上关于家系识别、招募方法或预期参与率的相关内容几乎没有发表过。在此,我们描述了一项基因连锁研究中用于数据收集的策略,以为高效设计新研究提供指导方针。
从私人医生、诊所及自我推荐中确定潜在符合条件的家系。根据确定来源、初次接触方式、性别和种族,在招募过程的每个步骤中检查参与率。
在确定的320个潜在符合条件的家系中,仅有68个(21%)成功入组。83%的家系与索引对象建立了联系,其中88%完成了资格筛查。然而,仅54%经筛查的家系被确认符合条件,而在这些家系中,只有54%被入组。在符合条件的家系中,79%的索引对象同意参与;较低的家系入组率主要是由于连锁分析所需的其他家庭成员拒绝参与。在招募过程的每个步骤中,自我推荐的家系参与率高于其他家系。
招募家系进行遗传学研究是劳动密集型的;对于每个入组的家系,可能必须筛查许多潜在符合条件的家系。自我推荐的家系比通过其他方法确定的家系招募起来更容易。引入从临床环境中识别符合条件家系的标准化方法可提高效率。