Murai Mitsuya, Kitamura Kazuya, Fetters Michael D
Kashima Hospital, Kashima City, Japan.
BMC Med Educ. 2005 Sep 15;5:33. doi: 10.1186/1472-6920-5-33.
While family medicine is not well established as a discipline in Japan, a growing number of Japanese medical schools and training hospitals have recently started sougoushinryoubu (general medicine departments). Some of these departments are incorporating a family medicine approach to residency training. We sought to learn from family medicine pioneers of these programs lessons for developing residency training.
This qualitative project utilized a long interview research design. Questions focused on four topics: 1) circumstances when becoming chair/faculty member; 2) approach to starting the program; 3) how Western ideas of family medicine were incorporated; and 4) future directions. We analyzed the data using immersion/crystallization to identify recurring themes. From the transcribed data, we selected representative quotations to illustrate them. We verified the findings by emailing the participants and obtaining feedback.
Participants included: five chairpersons, two program directors, and three faculty members. We identified five lessons: 1) few people understand the basic concepts of family medicine; 2) developing a core curriculum is difficult; 3) start with undergraduates; 4) emphasize clinical skills; and 5) train in the community.
While organizational change is difficult, the identified lessons suggest issues that merit consideration when developing a family medicine training program. Lessons from complexity science could inform application of these insights in other countries and settings newly developing residency training.
虽然家庭医学在日本尚未作为一门成熟学科确立,但最近越来越多的日本医学院校和培训医院开始设立综合诊疗部。其中一些部门正在将家庭医学方法纳入住院医师培训。我们试图从这些项目的家庭医学先驱那里汲取经验教训,以发展住院医师培训。
这个定性项目采用了长时间访谈研究设计。问题集中在四个主题上:1)成为主任/教员时的情况;2)启动该项目的方法;3)如何融入西方家庭医学理念;4)未来方向。我们使用沉浸/结晶法分析数据以识别反复出现的主题。从转录数据中,我们挑选了具有代表性的引语来说明这些主题。我们通过给参与者发电子邮件并获得反馈来验证研究结果。
参与者包括:五位主任、两位项目主任和三位教员。我们确定了五点经验教训:1)很少有人理解家庭医学的基本概念;2)制定核心课程很困难;3)从本科生开始;4)强调临床技能;5)在社区进行培训。
虽然组织变革困难,但确定的经验教训表明了在制定家庭医学培训项目时值得考虑的问题。复杂性科学的经验教训可为在其他新开展住院医师培训的国家和环境中应用这些见解提供参考。