Caravati E Martin, Erdman Andrew R, Christianson Gwenn, Manoguerra Anthony S, Booze Lisa L, Woolf Alan D, Olson Kent R, Chyka Peter A, Scharman Elizabeth J, Wax Paul M, Keyes Daniel C, Troutman William G
American Association of Poison Control Centers, Washington, DC 20016, USA.
Clin Toxicol (Phila). 2005;43(5):327-45. doi: 10.1080/07313820500184971.
In 2002, poison centers in the US reported 5816 human exposures to ethylene glycol. A guideline that effectively determines the threshold dose for emergency department referral and need for pre-hospital decontamination could potentially avoid unnecessary emergency department visits, reduce health care costs, optimize patient outcome, and reduce life disruption for patients and caregivers. An evidence-based expert consensus process was used to create this guideline. Relevant articles were abstracted by a trained physician researcher. The first draft of the guideline was created by the primary author. The entire panel discussed and refined the guideline before distribution to secondary reviewers for comment. The panel then made changes based on the secondary review comments. The objective of this guideline is to assist poison center personnel in the out-of-hospital triage and initial management of patients with a suspected exposure to ethylene glycol by (1) describing the process by which the exposure might be evaluated, (2) identifying the key decision elements in managing the case, (3) providing clear and practical recommendations that reflect the current state of knowledge, and (4) identifying needs for research. This guideline is based on an assessment of current scientific and clinical information. The panel recognizes that specific patient care decisions may be at variance with this guideline and are the prerogative of the patient and health professionals providing care, considering all of the circumstances involved. Recommendations are in chronological order of likely clinical use. The grade of recommendation is in parentheses. (1) A patient with exposure due to suspected self-harm, misuse, or potentially malicious administration should be referred to an emergency department immediately regardless of the dose reported (Grade D). (2) Patients with inhalation exposures will not develop systemic toxicity and can be managed out-of-hospital if asymptomatic (Grade B). Patients with clinically significant mucous membrane irritation should be referred for evaluation (Grade D). (3) Decontamination of dermal exposures should include routine cleansing with mild soap and water. Removal of contact lenses and immediate irrigation with room temperature tap water is recommended for ocular exposures. All patients with symptoms of eye injury should be referred for an ophthalmologic exam (Grade D). (4) Patients with symptoms of ethylene glycol poisoning should be referred immediately for evaluation regardless of the reported dose (Grade C). (5) The absence of symptoms shortly after ingestion does not exclude a potentially toxic dose and should not be used as a triage criterion (Grade C). (6) Adults who ingest a "swallow" (10-30 mL), children who ingest more than a witnessed taste or lick, or if the amount is unknown of most ethylene glycol products should be referred immediately for evaluation. The potential toxic volume of dilute solutions (e.g., concentration <20%) is larger and can be estimated by a formula in the text (Grade C). (7) A witnessed taste or lick only by a child, or an adult who unintentionally drinks and then expectorates the product without swallowing, does not need referral (Grade C). (8) Referral is not needed if it has been >24 hours since a potentially toxic unintentional exposure, the patient has been asymptomatic, and no alcohol was co-ingested (Grade D). (9) Gastrointestinal decontamination with ipecac syrup, gastric lavage or activated charcoal is not recommended. Transportation to an emergency department should not be delayed for any decontamination procedures (Grade D). (10) Patients meeting referral criteria should be evaluated at a hospital emergency department rather than a clinic. A facility that can quickly obtain an ethylene glycol serum concentration and has alcohol or fomepizole therapy available is preferred. This referral should be guided by local poison center procedures and community resources (Grade D). (11) The administration of alcohol, fomepizole, thiamine, or pyridoxine is not recommended in the out-of-hospital setting (Grade D).
2002年,美国毒物控制中心报告了5816起乙二醇人体暴露事件。一项能有效确定急诊科转诊阈值剂量以及院前去污需求的指南,有可能避免不必要的急诊科就诊,降低医疗成本,优化患者治疗效果,并减少患者及其护理人员的生活干扰。本指南采用循证专家共识流程制定。相关文章由一名经过培训的内科医师研究员进行摘要。指南初稿由第一作者撰写。在分发给二级审阅者征求意见之前,整个小组对指南进行了讨论和完善。然后,小组根据二级审阅意见进行了修改。本指南的目的是通过以下方式协助毒物控制中心人员对疑似乙二醇暴露患者进行院外分诊和初始处理:(1)描述评估暴露情况的过程;(2)确定处理该病例的关键决策要素;(3)提供反映当前知识水平的清晰实用建议;(4)确定研究需求。本指南基于对当前科学和临床信息的评估。小组认识到,特定的患者护理决策可能与本指南不一致,在考虑所有相关情况后,这是患者和提供护理的卫生专业人员的特权。建议按照可能的临床使用时间顺序排列。推荐等级在括号内。(1)因疑似自残、误用或潜在恶意投药而暴露的患者,无论报告的剂量如何,均应立即转诊至急诊科(D级)。(2)吸入性暴露患者不会出现全身毒性,如无症状可在院外处理(B级)。有临床显著黏膜刺激症状的患者应转诊进行评估(D级)。(3)皮肤暴露的去污应包括用温和肥皂和水进行常规清洗。眼部暴露建议摘除隐形眼镜并用室温自来水立即冲洗。所有有眼部损伤症状的患者应转诊进行眼科检查(D级)。(4)有乙二醇中毒症状的患者,无论报告的剂量如何,均应立即转诊进行评估(C级)。(5)摄入后不久无症状并不排除潜在中毒剂量,不应将其用作分诊标准(C级)。(6)摄入“一口”(10 - 30毫升)的成年人、摄入超过目睹的一口量或舔舐量的儿童,或如果乙二醇产品的摄入量未知,均应立即转诊进行评估。稀释溶液(如浓度<20%)的潜在中毒量较大,可通过文中公式估算(C级)。(7)仅儿童目睹的舔舐,或成年人无意中饮用后吐出产品未吞咽,无需转诊(C级)。(8)如果潜在有毒的无意暴露已超过24小时,患者无症状且未同时摄入酒精,则无需转诊(D级)。(9)不建议用吐根糖浆、洗胃或活性炭进行胃肠道去污。不应因任何去污程序而延迟送往急诊科(D级)。(10)符合转诊标准的患者应在医院急诊科而非诊所进行评估。首选能快速获得乙二醇血清浓度且有酒精或甲吡唑治疗可用的机构。此转诊应遵循当地毒物控制中心程序和社区资源(D级)。(11)不建议在院外环境中给予酒精、甲吡唑、硫胺素或吡哆醇(D级)。