Mills Edward J, Singh Sonal, Holtz Timothy H, Chase Robert M, Dolma Sonam, Santa-Barbara Joanna, Orbinski James J
Dept. of Clinical Epidemiology & Biostatistics, McMaster University, Hamilton, Canada.
BMC Int Health Hum Rights. 2005 Nov 9;5:7. doi: 10.1186/1472-698X-5-7.
Many Tibetan refugees flee Tibet in order to escape physical and mental hardships, and to access the freedoms to practice their culture and religion. We aimed to determine the prevalence of mental illnesses within the refugee population and determine the prevalence of previous torture reported within this population.
We performed a systematic literature search of 10 electronic databases from inception to May 2005. In addition, we searched the internet, contacted all authors of located studies, and contacted the Tibetan Government-in-exile, to locate unpublished studies. We included any study reporting on prevalence of mental illness within the Tibetan refugee populations. We determined study quality according to validation, translation, and interview administration. We calculated proportions with exact confidence intervals.
Five studies that met our inclusion criteria (total n = 410). All studies were conducted in North India and 4 were specifically in adult populations. Four studies provided details on the prevalence of torture and previous imprisonment within the populations. The prevalence of post-traumatic stress disorder ranged from 11-23%, anxiety ranged from 25-77%, and major depression ranged from 11.5-57%.
Our review indicates that the prevalence of serious mental health disorders within this population is elevated. The reported incidence of torture and imprisonment is a possible contributor to the illnesses. Non-government organizations and international communities should be aware of the human rights abuses being levied upon this vulnerable population and the mental health outcomes that may be associated with it.
许多藏族难民逃离西藏,以逃避身心磨难,并获得践行其文化和宗教的自由。我们旨在确定难民群体中心理疾病的患病率,并确定该群体中报告的既往遭受酷刑的患病率。
我们对10个电子数据库进行了从建库至2005年5月的系统文献检索。此外,我们还搜索了互联网,联系了所找到研究的所有作者,并联系了流亡藏人政府,以查找未发表的研究。我们纳入了任何报告藏族难民群体中心理疾病患病率的研究。我们根据验证、翻译和访谈管理来确定研究质量。我们计算了带有精确置信区间的比例。
五项研究符合我们的纳入标准(总计n = 410)。所有研究均在印度北部进行,其中四项专门针对成年人群体。四项研究提供了该群体中遭受酷刑和既往被监禁情况的患病率细节。创伤后应激障碍的患病率在11% - 23%之间,焦虑症患病率在25% - 77%之间,重度抑郁症患病率在11.5% - 57%之间。
我们的综述表明,该群体中严重心理健康障碍的患病率有所升高。报告的酷刑和监禁发生率可能是导致这些疾病的一个因素。非政府组织和国际社会应意识到对这一弱势群体的人权侵犯以及可能与之相关的心理健康后果。