Edge Johann, Bishop David, Goodman Carmel, Dawson Brian
School of Human Movement and Exercise Science, The University of Western Australia, Perth.
Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2005 Nov;37(11):1975-82. doi: 10.1249/01.mss.0000175855.35403.4c.
We compared the effects of high-intensity interval (HIT) and moderate-intensity continuous (MIT) training (matched for total work) on changes in repeated-sprint ability (RSA) and muscle metabolism.
Pre- and posttraining, VO(2peak), lactate threshold (LT), and RSA (5 x 6-s sprints, every 30 s) were assessed in 20 females. Before and immediately after the RSA test, muscle biopsies were taken from the vastus lateralis. Subjects were matched on RSA, randomly placed into the HIT (N = 10) or MIT (N = 10) group and performed 5 wk (3 d.wk(-1)) of cycle training; performing either HIT (6-10, 2-min intervals at 120-140% LT) or MIT (continuous, 20-30 min at 80-95% LT).
Both groups had significant improvements in VO(2peak) (10-12%; P < 0.05) and LT (8-10%; P < 0.05), with no significant differences between them. Both groups also had significant increases in RSA total work (kJ) (P < 0.05), with a significantly greater increase following HIT than MIT (13 vs 8.5%, respectively; P < 0.05). There was a significant decrease in resting [ATP] and an increase in postexercise La(-) for both groups, but no significant differences between them. There were no significant changes in resting or postexercise [PCr], [Cr], muscle [La(-)], or [H(+)] after the training period.
When total work is matched, HIT results in greater improvements in RSA than MIT. This results from an improved ability to maintain performance during consecutive sprints, which is not explained by differences in work done during the first sprint, aerobic fitness or metabolite accumulation at the end of the sprints.
我们比较了高强度间歇训练(HIT)和中等强度持续训练(MIT)(总运动量匹配)对反复冲刺能力(RSA)和肌肉代谢变化的影响。
对20名女性进行训练前和训练后评估,测量其最大摄氧量(VO₂peak)、乳酸阈值(LT)和RSA(每30秒进行5次6秒冲刺)。在RSA测试前和测试后立即,从股外侧肌取肌肉活检样本。根据RSA将受试者匹配,随机分为HIT组(N = 10)或MIT组(N = 10),并进行5周(每周3天)的自行车训练;HIT组进行(6 - 10次,2分钟间歇,强度为LT的120 - 140%),MIT组进行(持续20 - 30分钟,强度为LT的80 - 95%)。
两组的VO₂peak(提高10 - 12%;P < 0.05)和LT(提高8 - 10%;P < 0.05)均有显著改善,且两组之间无显著差异。两组的RSA总功(kJ)也均显著增加(P < 0.05),HIT组的增加幅度显著大于MIT组(分别为13%和8.5%;P < 0.05)。两组的静息[ATP]均显著降低,运动后La⁻均升高,但两组之间无显著差异。训练期后,静息或运动后的[PCr]、[Cr]、肌肉[La⁻]或[H⁺]均无显著变化。
当总运动量匹配时,HIT比MIT能使RSA得到更大改善。这是由于在连续冲刺过程中维持运动表现的能力提高,这并非由第一次冲刺时的运动量、有氧适能或冲刺结束时的代谢物积累差异所解释。