Eng P A, Borer-Reinhold M, Heijnen I A F M, Gnehm H P E
Department of Pediatrics, Kantonsspital Aarau, Aarau, Switzerland.
Allergy. 2006 Feb;61(2):198-201. doi: 10.1111/j.1398-9995.2006.01011.x.
In a previous controlled study, we demonstrated that preseasonal grass pollen immunotherapy for 3 years was effective in children. Moreover, a significant clinical benefit could still be observed 6 years after discontinuation of specific immunotherapy (SIT). In the current study, we examined the same group of patients again to investigate whether there is a prolonged benefit 12 years after SIT is stopped.
Twenty-two patients with previous SIT (from 1989 through 1991) or standardized seasonal pharmacotherapy only were prospectively followed during the grass pollen season of 2003. Primary end points were symptom score, medication use, and combined symptom and medication score. In addition, skin prick test reactivity, development of new sensitizations, and prevalence of seasonal asthma were evaluated.
Total hay fever symptom score (P < 0.03), use of medication (P < 0.05), and combined symptom and medication score (P < 0.03) remained lower in patients with previous SIT when compared with the control group. Decreased immediate skin response to grass pollen returned 12 years after cessation of SIT. The percentage of new sensitization, however, continued to be significantly smaller in patients with previous SIT (58%) compared with the controls (100%, P < 0.05). There was a tendency for lower prevalence of seasonal asthma in the post-SIT group (P = 0.08).
This prospective controlled prolonged follow-up study demonstrates the ongoing clinical benefit 12 years after discontinuation of SIT. Furthermore, the reduction in onset of new sensitization, which was found 6 years after discontinuation of SIT, is sustained 6 years later.
在之前的一项对照研究中,我们证明了为期3年的季节性草花粉免疫疗法对儿童有效。此外,在特异性免疫疗法(SIT)停止6年后仍可观察到显著的临床益处。在本研究中,我们再次对同一组患者进行检查,以调查SIT停止12年后是否存在长期益处。
2003年草花粉季节期间,对22例曾接受SIT(1989年至1991年)或仅接受标准化季节性药物治疗的患者进行前瞻性随访。主要终点为症状评分、药物使用情况以及症状与药物综合评分。此外,还评估了皮肤点刺试验反应性、新致敏的发生情况以及季节性哮喘的患病率。
与对照组相比,曾接受SIT的患者的总花粉症症状评分(P < 0.03)、药物使用情况(P < 0.05)以及症状与药物综合评分(P < 0.03)仍较低。SIT停止12年后,对草花粉的即时皮肤反应降低的情况又出现了。然而,与对照组(100%)相比,曾接受SIT的患者中新致敏的百分比仍显著较低(58%,P < 0.05)。SIT后组的季节性哮喘患病率有降低的趋势(P = 0.08)。
这项前瞻性对照长期随访研究表明,SIT停止12年后仍有持续的临床益处。此外,SIT停止6年后发现的新致敏发生率的降低在6年后仍持续存在。