Hamilton Lynnae A, Aliyu Muktar H, Lyons Paul D, May Roberta, Swanson Charlie L, Savage Robert, Go Rodney C P
Fielding Graduate University, Santa Barbara, CA, USA.
J Natl Med Assoc. 2006 Jan;98(1):18-27.
Ensuring adequate representation of all demographic groups in medical research is necessary in order to ensure that the benefits associated with participation are equitably shared. Mental health research is unique in that the stigma associated with mental illness, such as schizophrenia, further hinders participation. Using focus groups, we set out to explore the attitudes and views of African Americans with regard to schizophrenia and medical research.
Four focus group discussions were conducted, with 23 participants divided into two groups of working and retired adults, and two groups of full- and part-time students selected from inner-city residents of Birmingham, AL, and surrounding counties. Data obtained were analyzed using the content analysis method.
Diverse views were expressed about the cause of mental illness, and much of this was influenced by cultural beliefs. There was considerable misunderstanding of schizophrenia, and the majority of participants described the disease in terms of positive symptoms only. Whereas for older participants the Tuskegee syphilis study experience was an important factor in their reluctance to participate in medical research, younger participants expressed no knowledge of the study. Among younger participants an assumed level of social distrust was evident, with prominent fear of participating in research that employs physically intrusive methods.
The provision of accurate information through trusted community sources and open dialogue will help to dispel myths, correct faulty assumptions and increase African-American participation in schizophrenia research.
为确保参与医学研究的益处能公平分配,必须保证医学研究能充分代表所有人口群体。心理健康研究具有独特性,因为与精神疾病(如精神分裂症)相关的污名进一步阻碍了人们的参与。我们通过焦点小组来探究非裔美国人对精神分裂症和医学研究的态度与看法。
进行了四次焦点小组讨论,23名参与者分为两组,一组是在职和退休成年人,另一组是从阿拉巴马州伯明翰市及周边县的市中心居民中选取的全日制和非全日制学生。使用内容分析法对获得的数据进行分析。
参与者对精神疾病的病因表达了多种观点,其中很多受到文化信仰的影响。对精神分裂症存在相当多的误解,大多数参与者仅从阳性症状方面描述该疾病。对于年长参与者而言,塔斯基吉梅毒研究经历是他们不愿参与医学研究的一个重要因素,而年轻参与者表示对该研究一无所知。在年轻参与者中,明显存在一种假定的社会不信任,他们极度害怕参与采用身体侵入性方法的研究。
通过可靠的社区渠道提供准确信息并开展开放对话,将有助于消除误解、纠正错误假设,并提高非裔美国人参与精神分裂症研究的比例。