Kochar N, Tripathi D, Ireland H, Redhead D N, Hayes P C
Department of Hepatology, Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh, 51 Little France Crescent, Edinburgh EH16 4SU, UK.
Gut. 2006 Nov;55(11):1617-23. doi: 10.1136/gut.2005.089482. Epub 2006 Mar 29.
Post-transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic stent shunt (TIPSS) hepatic encephalopathy (HE) can occur in up to one third of patients. In 5%, this can be refractory to optimal medical treatment and may require shunt modification. The efficacy of shunt modification has been poorly studied.
To evaluate the efficacy of and natural history following TIPSS modification for treatment of refractory HE.
From a dedicated database, we selected and further studied patients who had TIPSS modification for refractory HE.
Over a 14 year period, of 733 TIPSS insertions, 211(29%) patients developed HE post-TIPSS. In 38 patients, shunt modification (reduction (n = 9) and occlusion (n = 29)) was performed for refractory HE. Indications for TIPSS were: variceal bleeding (n = 32), refractory ascites (n = 5), and other (n = 1). Child's grades A, B, and C were noted in 11%, 47%, and 42% of cases, respectively. HE improved in 58% of patients and remained unchanged or worsened in 42%, with similar results for occlusions and reductions. Following shunt modification, variceal bleeding recurred in three patients and ascites in three. Twenty five patients have died (liver related in 15) at a median duration of 10.2 months. Three patients died due to procedure related complications following shunt occlusions (mesenteric infarction (n = 2) and septicaemia (n = 1)). Median survival of patients whose HE did not improve following shunt modification was 79 days compared with 278 days in patients whose did (p<0.05). No variables independently predicted response to shunt modification.
TIPSS modification is a useful option for patients with refractory HE following TIPSS insertion. Due to the significant risk of iatrogenic complications with shunt occlusions, shunt reduction is a safer and preferred option.
经颈静脉肝内门体分流术(TIPSS)后肝性脑病(HE)在多达三分之一的患者中会发生。5%的患者对此可能对最佳药物治疗无效,可能需要修改分流术。分流术修改的疗效研究较少。
评估TIPSS修改治疗难治性HE的疗效及自然病程。
从一个专门的数据库中,我们选择并进一步研究了因难治性HE而进行TIPSS修改的患者。
在14年期间,733例TIPSS植入患者中,211例(29%)在TIPSS后发生HE。38例患者因难治性HE进行了分流术修改(缩小(n = 9)和闭塞(n = 29))。TIPSS的适应证为:静脉曲张出血(n = 32)、难治性腹水(n = 5)和其他(n = 1)。分别有11%、47%和42%的病例为Child's A、B和C级。58%的患者HE改善,42%的患者无变化或恶化,闭塞和缩小的结果相似。分流术修改后,3例患者静脉曲张出血复发,3例患者腹水复发。25例患者死亡(15例与肝脏相关),中位持续时间为10.2个月。3例患者在分流闭塞后因手术相关并发症死亡(肠系膜梗死(n = 2)和败血症(n = 1))。分流术修改后HE未改善的患者中位生存期为79天,而改善的患者为278天(p<0.05)。没有变量能独立预测对分流术修改的反应。
TIPSS修改对于TIPSS植入后难治性HE患者是一种有用的选择。由于分流闭塞存在显著的医源性并发症风险,分流缩小是一种更安全且更可取的选择。