Franzini Luisa, Fernandez-Esquer Maria Eugenia
University of Texas, School of Public Health, Houston, TX, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2006 Aug;63(3):788-804. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2006.01.009. Epub 2006 Mar 31.
There is only limited research on subjective social status (SSS) and its effect on health in general and in minority US populations in particular. This study first investigates the determinants of SSS and the relationship between SSS and objective social status. It then explores the relationships of SSS to self-reported physical health, self-reported mental health, and self-rated health (SRH). The study population consists of Mexican-origin individuals living in low-income neighborhoods in Texas and grouped into acculturation categories based on nativity and use of the Spanish language. We also investigate the role of reference groups. Results indicate that there is no disjuncture between subjective and objective status in this population but that the less acculturated groups rank their social status based on different criteria than the more acculturated. People compare themselves mainly with those similar to them and average subjective status in the different acculturation groups accurately reflects the objective status of the group. Sociocultural factors, in particular perceived differences in opportunities, explain differences between subjective and objective status. Subjective status was associated with all health outcomes. When controlling for objective status, subjective status was associated with mental health and SRH but not with physical health. Objective status indicators were consistently associated with all health outcomes, indicating the prominence of objective socioeconomic status in affecting health in this low-income minority population. Sociocultural characteristics appear to mediate the effect of SSS on health. In particular, perceived victimization might mediate the effect of SSS on mental health.
关于主观社会地位(SSS)及其对总体健康尤其是美国少数族裔健康的影响,相关研究有限。本研究首先调查了SSS的决定因素以及SSS与客观社会地位之间的关系。接着,探讨了SSS与自我报告的身体健康、自我报告的心理健康以及自评健康(SRH)之间的关系。研究人群为居住在得克萨斯州低收入社区的墨西哥裔个体,并根据出生地和西班牙语使用情况分为文化适应类别。我们还研究了参照群体的作用。结果表明,该人群的主观和客观地位之间没有脱节,但文化适应程度较低的群体根据与文化适应程度较高的群体不同的标准来对其社会地位进行排名。人们主要将自己与类似的人进行比较,不同文化适应群体的平均主观地位准确反映了该群体的客观地位。社会文化因素,尤其是感知到的机会差异,解释了主观和客观地位之间的差异。主观地位与所有健康结果相关。在控制客观地位后,主观地位与心理健康和SRH相关,但与身体健康无关。客观地位指标始终与所有健康结果相关,表明客观社会经济地位在影响这个低收入少数族裔人群健康方面的突出作用。社会文化特征似乎介导了SSS对健康的影响。特别是,感知到的受害情况可能介导了SSS对心理健康的影响。