Ferroli P, Casazza M, Marras C, Mendola C, Franzini A, Broggi G
Department of Neurosurgery, Istituto Nazionale Neurologico C. Besta, Milan, Italy.
Neurol Sci. 2006 Feb;26(6):390-4. doi: 10.1007/s10072-006-0521-2.
The objective was to evaluate the outcome of microsurgical "pure" lesionectomy in patients with supratentorial cavernous angiomas presenting with seizures. For this retrospective study 163 patients with cavernoma-related epileptic seizures were selected. They all underwent surgery in a single institution between 1988 and 2003. A microsurgical frame/frameless guided minimally invasive transulcal "pure" lesionectomy was performed. The haemosiderin stained gliotic brain parenchyma that was usually found surrounding the lesion was not removed. Among the 99 patients with epilepsy and longer clinical history, 68 (68.7%) were found completely to be seizure-free, 10 (10.1%) presented sporadic and less frequent seizures and 17 (17.1%) remained unchanged. Sixty-three out of 64 (98.4%) patients who experienced only single or sporadic seizures were found to be completely seizure-free after surgery. Five patients were lost at follow-up (mean 48 months, range 0.5-14 years). Long-term morbidity was 1.8%. Mortality was null. No haemorrhagic episodes were observed during follow-up. Pure lesionectomy prevents bleeding and development of epilepsy in patients that receive early surgery after the epileptic onset. In most of the epileptic patients with a good concordance between the electroclinical data and the location of the angioma, good results can be achieved by this kind of surgery so that more invasive and costly studies to find and remove the epileptogenic cerebral parenchyma seem justified only after lesionectomy fails.
目的是评估幕上海绵状血管瘤伴癫痫发作患者行显微外科“单纯”病灶切除术的效果。在这项回顾性研究中,选取了163例与海绵状血管瘤相关的癫痫发作患者。他们均于1988年至2003年在同一机构接受手术。采用显微外科框架/无框架引导下的微创经脑沟“单纯”病灶切除术。通常在病灶周围发现的含铁血黄素染色的胶质化脑实质未被切除。在99例癫痫病史较长的患者中,68例(68.7%)完全无癫痫发作,10例(10.1%)有散在且发作频率较低的癫痫发作,17例(17.1%)病情无变化。64例仅经历单次或散在癫痫发作的患者中,63例(98.4%)术后完全无癫痫发作。5例患者失访(平均48个月,范围0.5 - 14年)。长期发病率为1.8%。死亡率为零。随访期间未观察到出血事件。单纯病灶切除术可预防癫痫发作后早期接受手术的患者出血及癫痫的发生。对于大多数电临床数据与血管瘤位置良好匹配的癫痫患者,通过这种手术可取得良好效果,因此,只有在病灶切除术失败后,进行更具侵入性和成本更高的寻找并切除致痫脑实质的研究才似乎合理。