Misra U K, Kalita J, Mishra V N, Phadke R V, Hadique A
Department of Neurology, Sanjay Gandhi Post Graduate Institute of Medical Sciences, Raebareily Road, Lucknow 226014, India.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2006 May;77(5):695-8. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.2005.082362.
Flexion myelopathy is one of the suggested mechanism for Hirayama disease (HD) but simultaneous radiological and neurophysiological evaluation is lacking. This study therefore evaluates the effect of neck flexion in HD using somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs), F waves, and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).
Eight HD patients and seven matched controls were subjected to median and ulnar F wave (minimal latency, FM ratio, persistence, and chronodispersion), and SEPs evaluating N9, N13, and N20 potentials in neutral and neck flexion. Spinal MRI was carried out in neutral and neck flexion and evaluated for cord atrophy, signal changes, cord compression, posterior epidural tissue, and loss of dural attachment.
The patients were aged 19 to 30 years. Minimal F latency, FM ratio, persistence, and chronodispersion in neutral and neck flexion did not show any change nor was there any change in N13 latency and amplitude on median and ulnar SEPs. The difference in these parameters in neutral and neck flexion were also not significant in HD compared with controls. The change in N13 was also not related to loss of dural attachment and posterior epidural tissue.
Neck flexion does not produce significant changes in N13 and F wave parameters and is not related to dynamic MRI changes. The other mechanisms for HD should therefore be explored.
屈曲型脊髓病是平山病(HD)的一种推测机制,但缺乏同时进行的放射学和神经生理学评估。因此,本研究使用体感诱发电位(SEP)、F波和磁共振成像(MRI)评估颈部屈曲对HD的影响。
对8例HD患者和7例匹配的对照者进行正中神经和尺神经F波(最小潜伏期、F波比率、波幅持续时间和时限离散度)检查,以及在中立位和颈部屈曲位评估N9、N13和N20电位的SEP检查。在中立位和颈部屈曲位进行脊髓MRI检查,并评估脊髓萎缩、信号变化、脊髓受压、硬膜外组织及硬脊膜附着丧失情况。
患者年龄为19至30岁。中立位和颈部屈曲位的F波最小潜伏期、F波比率、波幅持续时间和时限离散度均未显示任何变化,正中神经和尺神经SEP的N13潜伏期和波幅也未发生变化。与对照组相比,HD患者中立位和颈部屈曲位这些参数的差异也不显著。N13的变化也与硬脊膜附着丧失和硬膜外组织无关。
颈部屈曲不会使N13和F波参数产生显著变化,且与动态MRI变化无关。因此,应探索HD的其他机制。