Gillies Val
Families & Social Capital Group, London South Bank University.
Community Pract. 2006 Apr;79(4):114-7.
This paper highlights the central role of social class in shaping experiences of childrearing. Drawing on material from qualitative interviews with a range of working class mothers it explores and contextualises day-to-day family practices. It examines the different ways in which parents cope with disadvantage and shows how their decisions and practices are grounded in a material and social reality. In contrast to evaluative and outcome-focused literature on parenting, it demonstrates how decisions and practices that make less sense from a middle class vantage point shift their meaning when viewed from a working class perspective. The paper illustrates how the promotion of parenting 'skills' as neutral technical tips obscures normative, culturally specific assumptions about what constitutes successful childrearing. The implications of this for health visitors' practice will be considered.
本文强调了社会阶层在塑造育儿经历中的核心作用。借助对一系列工人阶级母亲进行定性访谈所获得的材料,探讨并将日常家庭实践置于具体情境中。它考察了父母应对不利处境的不同方式,并展示了他们的决策和实践是如何基于物质和社会现实的。与以评价和结果为重点的育儿文献不同,它表明从中产阶级视角看似不合理的决策和实践,从工人阶级视角来看却有了不同的意义。本文说明了将育儿“技巧”作为中立的技术提示进行推广,是如何掩盖了关于何为成功育儿的规范性、文化特定假设的。将考虑这对健康访视员实践的影响。