Hall Ailsa J, Hugunin Kelly, Deaville Robert, Law Robin J, Allchin Colin R, Jepson Paul D
Sea Mammal Research Unit, Gatty Marine Laboratory, University of St. Andrews, St. Andrews, Fife, United Kingdom.
Environ Health Perspect. 2006 May;114(5):704-11. doi: 10.1289/ehp.8222.
The objective of this study was to determine whether the risk of mortality from infectious disease in harbor porpoise in U.K. waters increased with high exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), using a case-control study design. This is the first time that data from a long-term marine mammal strandings scheme have been used to estimate any increase in risk. The exposure odds ratio (OR) from a logistic regression model with infectious disease deaths as cases and physical trauma deaths as controls, after controlling for the effect of confounding factors, was 1.048 [95% confidence interval (CI), 1.02-1.07]. To further adjust for the difference in energetic status between cases and controls and account for the negative relationship between PCBs (sum of 25 chlorobiphenyl congeners) and blubber mass, we also "standardized" the blubber PCBs to an optimal blubber mass. This lowered the OR to 1.02 (95% CI, 1.00-1.03). Thus, for each 1 mg/kg increase in blubber PCBs, the average increase in risk of infectious disease mortality was 2%. A doubling of risk occurred at approximately 45 mg/kg lipid. In this study, we have endeavored to avoid selection bias by using controls that died of physical trauma as representative of the exposure prevalence in the population that gave rise to the cases. In addition, we controlled for the effect of variation in energetic status among the cases and controls. However, as with case-control studies in human and veterinary epidemiology, unforeseen misclassification errors may result in biased risk estimates in either direction.
本研究的目的是采用病例对照研究设计,确定英国海域港湾鼠海豚因接触高浓度多氯联苯(PCBs)而导致传染病死亡的风险是否增加。这是首次使用长期海洋哺乳动物搁浅计划的数据来估计风险的任何增加情况。在控制混杂因素的影响后,以传染病死亡为病例、身体创伤死亡为对照的逻辑回归模型得出的暴露优势比(OR)为1.048 [95%置信区间(CI),1.02 - 1.07]。为了进一步调整病例与对照之间能量状态的差异,并考虑多氯联苯(25种氯联苯同系物的总和)与鲸脂质量之间的负相关关系,我们还将鲸脂中的多氯联苯“标准化”至最佳鲸脂质量。这使得优势比降至1.02(95% CI,1.00 - 1.03)。因此,鲸脂中多氯联苯每增加1 mg/kg,传染病死亡风险平均增加2%。在脂质含量约为45 mg/kg时,风险翻倍。在本研究中,我们努力通过使用因身体创伤死亡的对照来代表产生病例的人群中的暴露患病率,以避免选择偏倚。此外,我们控制了病例与对照之间能量状态变化的影响。然而,与人类和兽医流行病学中的病例对照研究一样,不可预见的错误分类误差可能导致风险估计在任何一个方向上出现偏差。