Sullivan Tara M, Bertrand Jane T, Rice Janet, Shelton James D
Center for Communication Programs, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, USA.
J Biosoc Sci. 2006 Jul;38(4):501-21. doi: 10.1017/S0021932005026647.
Contraceptive prevalence has been central to family planning research over the past few decades, but researchers have given surprisingly little consideration to method mix, a proxy for method availability or choice. There is no 'ideal' method mix recognized by the international community; however, there may be reason for concern when one or two methods predominate in a given country. In this article method skew is operationally defined as a single method constituting 50% or more of contraceptive use in a given country. Of 96 countries examined in this analysis, 34 have this type of skewed method mix. These 34 countries cluster in three groups: (1) sixteen countries in which traditional methods dominate, most of which are in sub-Saharan Africa; (2) four countries in which female sterilization predominates (India, Brazil, Dominican Republic and Panama); and (3) fourteen countries that rely on a single reversible method (the pill in Algeria, Kuwait, Liberia, Morocco, Sudan and Zimbabwe; the IUD in Cuba, Egypt, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyz Republic, Moldova, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan; and the injectable in Malawi). A review of available literature on method choice in these countries provides substantial insight into the different patterns of method skew. Method skew in some countries reflects cultural preferences or social norms. Yet it becomes problematic if it stems from restrictive population policies, lack of access to a broad range of methods, or provider bias.
在过去几十年里,避孕普及率一直是计划生育研究的核心内容,但研究人员对方法组合(一种衡量方法可获得性或选择的指标)的关注却出奇地少。国际社会并未认可一种“理想”的方法组合;然而,当一两种方法在某个国家占主导地位时,可能就有理由令人担忧了。在本文中,方法偏差在操作上被定义为在某个国家,单一方法的使用占避孕措施使用的50%或更多。在本次分析所考察的96个国家中,有34个国家存在这种方法组合偏差的情况。这34个国家可分为三组:(1)16个以传统方法为主的国家,其中大多数位于撒哈拉以南非洲;(2)4个以女性绝育为主的国家(印度、巴西、多米尼加共和国和巴拿马);(3)14个依赖单一可逆方法的国家(阿尔及利亚、科威特、利比里亚、摩洛哥、苏丹和津巴布韦使用避孕药;古巴、埃及、哈萨克斯坦、吉尔吉斯共和国、摩尔多瓦、土库曼斯坦和乌兹别克斯坦使用宫内节育器;马拉维使用注射剂)。对这些国家方法选择的现有文献进行综述,能让我们深入了解方法偏差的不同模式。一些国家的方法偏差反映了文化偏好或社会规范。然而,如果它源于限制性的人口政策、无法获得多种方法或提供者的偏见,那就会成为问题。